Philosophy

Article Philosophy

Empathy and the Value of Humane Understanding

Olivia Bailey

Summary: Empathy is an emotionally charged imaginative perspective-taking that plays a crucial role in interpersonal relationships. Humane understanding, as a non-instrumental value, meets people's need to be understood and has ethical significance.

PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Philosophy

Doing 'judgemental rationality' in empirical research: the importance of depth-reflexivity when researching in prison

Muzammil Quraishi, Lamia Irfan, Mallory Schneuwly Purdie, Matthew L. N. Wilkinson

Summary: This paper addresses the lack of tools for judgemental rationality in social science, proposing triangulation and depth-reflexivity as tools to fill this gap. Drawing on the experiences of a diverse team in an international comparative research project, it demonstrates how utilizing the 'laminated' properties and personal attributes of a team can bridge the epistemic and relational gaps between researchers and research subjects.

JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM (2022)

Article Philosophy

On Preferring that Overall, Things are Worse: Future-Bias and Unequal Payoffs

Preston Greene, Andrew J. Latham, Kristie Miller, James Norton

Summary: The study found that philosophers' predictions about hedonic bias towards the future, limited to first-person preferences, were inaccurate and there was no asymmetry between first-person and third-person conditions. This may not support arguments against the rationality of future bias. Additionally, an asymmetry between positive and negative events was discovered, which might provide new arguments in favor of time-neutralism.

PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Philosophy

On the Appropriateness of Grief to Its Object

Matthew Ratcliffe, Louise Richardson, Becky Millar

Summary: The nature and role of grief are determined by its object, and vice versa. This paper focuses on recent claims by philosophers that grief is irrational or inappropriate, and offers an alternative explanation by emphasizing the temporally extended structure of grief.

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL ASSOCIATION (2022)

Article Philosophy

How does Representational Transformation Enhance Mathematical Thinking?

Omid Khatin-Zadeh

Summary: Representational transformation helps in utilizing a wider range of cognitive resources, organizing scattered information into suitable units, suppressing irrelevant information, and discovering general rules, which enhances the efficiency of solving mathematical problems.

AXIOMATHES (2022)

Article History & Philosophy Of Science

Conceptual challenges for interpretable machine learning

David S. Watson

Summary: This article discusses three conceptual challenges that are often overlooked in interpretable machine learning (IML), including ambiguity in true target, disregard for error rates and rigorous testing, and an excessive emphasis on product over process. Through analyzing examples and counterexamples from IML, it demonstrates how ignoring these issues can lead to counterintuitive and potentially misleading explanations.

SYNTHESE (2022)

Article Philosophy

Realism and Political Normativity

Matt Sleat

Summary: The prevailing understanding of the difference between realism and moralism should not label realists as seeking a nonmoral political normativity, as much of realist work does not aspire to this. The focus should be on moving past unhelpful debates towards more fruitful constructive and critical discussions.

ETHICAL THEORY AND MORAL PRACTICE (2022)

Article Ethics

Global Laozegetics: A Study in Globalized Philosophy

Misha Tadd

JOURNAL OF THE HISTORY OF IDEAS (2022)

Article Philosophy

Critical phenomenology and psychiatry

Dan Zahavi, Sophie Loidolt

Summary: While classical Critical Theory has viewed phenomenology as lacking criticism, the recent development of critical phenomenology argues that phenomenological concepts and methods can be used to critically analyze social and political issues. However, some landmark publications in this field have overlooked the important contributions of psychiatry and psychopathology in the phenomenological tradition.

CONTINENTAL PHILOSOPHY REVIEW (2022)

Article Philosophy

Political realism as reformist conservatism

Greta Favara

Summary: Political realism can be interpreted as a form of reformist conservatism, which offers a middle ground between affirming the status quo and advocating radical transformations. This interpretation consistently reconciles the fundamental tenets of political realism and avoids the pitfalls of both conservative and radical interpretations.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY (2022)

Article Philosophy

The method of critical phenomenology: Simone de Beauvoir as a phenomenologist

Johanna Oksala

Summary: This paper contributes to the ongoing conversation on critical phenomenology by reflecting on its method. It argues that critical phenomenology should be understood as a historico-transcendental inquiry and that the phenomenological reduction should be incorporated in problematized and rethought forms. The assessment of critical phenomenology's method also has implications for reading its canon.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY (2023)

Article Philosophy

Sex Contextualism

Sarah S. Richardson

Summary: This paper introduces the conceptual framework of sex contextualism for the study of sex-related variables in biomedical research. Sex contextualism acknowledges the diversity and context-specificity of the operationalization of 'sex' in laboratory research, providing constructive guidance for biomedical researchers. It contributes to ongoing debates in philosophy of biology, feminist science studies, and social ontology on the construction of categories of gender/sex differences in scientific research.

ANALISIS FILOSOFICO (2022)

Article Philosophy

ACCOUNTABILITY AS A KEY VIRTUE IN MENTAL HEALTH AND HUMAN FLOURISHING

John R. Peteet, Charlotte V. O. Witvliet, C. Stephen Evans

Summary: This paper examines the overlooked role of accountability as a virtue in psychiatry, highlighting its importance in treatment and professionalism. It emphasizes the need for accountability that is interpersonally responsive and responsible in promoting mental health and flourishing.

PHILOSOPHY PSYCHIATRY & PSYCHOLOGY (2022)

Article Philosophy

Taking Watsuji online: betweenness and expression in online spaces

Lucy Osler, Joel Krueger

Summary: This paper introduces Tetsuro Watsuji's phenomenology of aidagara and applies it to the contemporary context of online space. The analysis anticipates modern forms of expression and engagement through communication technologies, highlighting the importance of emotional expression and shared experiences in online interactions. Watsuji's phenomenological perspective suggests that the Internet enables new forms of subjective spatiality, with hidden aspects of online interconnections having significant political and ethical implications.

CONTINENTAL PHILOSOPHY REVIEW (2022)

Article Philosophy

Fractal-Scaling Properties as Aesthetic Primitives in Vision and Touch

Catherine Viengkham, Zoey Isherwood, Branka Spehar

Summary: This article investigates the effects of fractal-like scaling characteristics on aesthetic preferences in different physical and sensory domains. The study finds that despite some differences, the underlying dimensional structure mediating cross-domain aesthetic preferences is remarkably similar.

AXIOMATHES (2022)

Article Philosophy

The significance of epistemic blame

Cameron Boult

Summary: This paper examines the distinction between epistemic blame and negative epistemic evaluation, criticizing a recent account by Jessica Brown and proposing an alternative approach that focuses on modifications to the intentions and expectations that underpin our epistemic relationships.

ERKENNTNIS (2023)

Article Philosophy

Distinctively Political Normativity in Political Realism: Unattractive or Redundant

Eva Erman, Niklas Moller

Summary: Political realists reject the 'ethics first' approach of political moralists and propose a distinctively political normativity, emphasizing the autonomy of politics. However, realists struggle to clarify the content and importance of this political normativity.

ETHICAL THEORY AND MORAL PRACTICE (2022)

Article Philosophy

A republic for all sentients: Social freedom without free will

Eze Paez

Summary: Most nonhuman animals are subjected to the terms imposed by humans, which is seen as political unfreedom in republicanism. However, extending this concept to animals poses challenges, especially in determining whether individuals without free will can benefit from freedom. Understanding the reasons that make freedom desirable for choices can help in predicating it to any sentient agent.

PACIFIC PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY (2022)

Article Philosophy

How to Philosophically Tackle Kinds without Talking about Natural Kinds

Ingo Brigandt

Summary: Recent attempts to develop a general theory of the properties that all natural kinds possess may have been futile, and instead, a general methodological framework for studying kinds from a philosophical perspective should be developed. This framework should consider human aims and non-epistemic goals. Furthermore, it is important to stop using the term "natural kinds" as it obscures the significance of human interests and the social processes that underlie many kinds.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY (2022)

Article Philosophy

How to phrase critical realist interview questions in applied social science research

Andreas Bronnimann

Summary: The lack of methodical guidance for qualitative interviewing in empirical realist literature is identified, and a guiding framework is proposed to assist researchers in phrasing more appropriate interview questions in realist research. The framework, based on critical and social realist concepts and guided by methodological realist principles, aims to improve research transparency and lead to increased validity and replicability of mechanism-based theories in empirical realist research.

JOURNAL OF CRITICAL REALISM (2022)