A simple mechanistic explanation for original antigenic sin and its alleviation by adjuvants

A large number of published studies have shown that adaptive immunity to a particular antigen, including pathogen-derived, can be boosted by another, cross-reacting antigen while inducing suboptimal immunity to the latter. Although this phenomenon, called original antigenic sin (OAS), was first reported approximately 70 years ago (Francis et al. 1947 Am. J. Public Health 37, 1013-1016 (doi:10.2105/AJPH.37.8.1013)), its underlying biological mechanisms are still inadequately understood (Kim et al. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, 13 751-13 756 (doi: 10.1073/pnas.0912458109)). Here, focusing on the humoral aspects of adaptive immunity, I propose a simple and testable mechanism: that OAS occurs when T regulatory cells induced by the first antigen decrease the dose of the second antigen that is loaded by dendritic cells and available to activate naive lymphocytes. I use both a parsimonious mathematical model and experimental data to confirm the deductive validity of this proposal. This model also explains the puzzling experimental observation that administering certain dendritic cell-activating adjuvants during antigen exposure alleviates OAS. Specifically, the model predicts that such adjuvants will attenuate T regulatory suppression of naive lymphocyte activation. Together, these results suggest additional strategies for redeeming adaptive immunity from the destructive consequences of antigenic 'sin'.