Is pituitary TSH an adequate measure of thyroid hormone-controlled homoeostasis during thyroxine treatment?

Objective: In recognition of its primary role in pituitary-thyroid feedback, TSH determination has become a key parameter for clinical decision-making. This study examines the value of TSH as a measure of thyroid hormone homoeostasis under thyroxine (T-4) therapy. Design and methods: We have examined the interrelationships between free triiodothyronine (FT3), free T-4 (FT4) and pituitary TSH by means of i) a retrospective analysis of a large clinical sample comprising 1994 patients either untreated or on varying doses of L-T-4 and ii) independent mathematical simulation applying a model of thyroid homoeostasis, together with a sensitivity analysis. Results: Over a euthyroid to mildly hyperthyroid functional range, we found markedly different correlation slopes of log TSH vs FT3 and FT4 between untreated patients and L-T-4 groups. Total deiodinase activity (G(D)) was positively correlated with TSH in untreated subjects. However, G(D) was significantly altered and the correlation was lost under increasing L-T-4 doses. Ninety-five per cent confidence intervals for FT3 and FT4, when assessed in defined TSH concentration bands, differed significantly for L-T-4-treated compared with untreated patients. Higher doses were often needed to restore FT3 levels within its reference range. Sensitivity analysis revealed the influence of various structural parameters on pituitary TSH secretion including an important role of pituitary deiodinase type 2. Conclusion: The data reveal disjoints between FT4-TSH feedback and T-3 production that persist even when sufficient T-4 apparently restores euthyroidism. T-4 treatment displays a compensatory adaptation but does not completely re-enact normal euthyroid physiology. This invites a study of the clinical consequences of this disparity. European Journal of Endocrinology 168 271-280