Differential Effect of Common Ligands and Molecular Oxygen on Antimicrobial Activity of Silver Nanoparticles versus Silver Ions

The antibacterial activity of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) is partially due to the release of Ag+, although discerning the contribution of AgNPs vs Ag+ is challenging due to their common co-occurrence. We discerned the toxicity of Ag+ versus a commercially available AgNP (35.4 +/- 5.1 nm, coated with amorphous carbon) by conducting antibacterial assays under anaerobic conditions that preclude Ag(0) oxidation, which is a prerequisite for Ag+ release. These AgNPs were 20x less toxic to E. coli than Ag+ (EC50: 2.04 +/- 0.07 vs 0.10 +/- 0.01 mg/L), and their toxicity increased 2.3-fold after exposure to air for 0.5 h (EC50: 0.87 +/- 0.03 mg/L) which promoted Ag+ release. No significant difference in Ag+ toxicity was observed between anaerobic and aerobic conditions, which rules out oxidative stress by ROS as an important antibacterial mechanism for Ag+. The toxicity of Ag+ (2.94 mu mol/L) was eliminated by equivalent cysteine or sulfide; the latter exceeded the solubility product equilibrium constant (K-sp), which is conducive to silver precipitation. Equivalent chloride and phosphate concentrations also reduced Ag+ toxicity without exceeding K-sp. Thus, some common ligands can hinder the bioavailability and mitigate the toxicity of Ag+ at relatively low concentrations that do not induce silver precipitation. Furthermore, low concentrations of chloride (0.1 mg/L) mitigated the toxicity of Ag+ but not that of AgNPs, suggesting that previous reports of higher AgNPs toxicity than their equivalent Ag+ concentration might be due to the presence of common ligands that preferentially decrease the bioavailability and toxicity of Ag+. Overall, these results show that the presence of O-2 or common ligands can differentially affect the toxicity of AgNPs vs Ag+, and underscore the importance of water chemistry in the mode of action of AgNPs.