Competitor-free space mediates non-target impact of an introduced biological control agent

1. Enemy-free space has been shown to mediate host shifts in herbivores, but this has not previously been documented in parasitoids. Also, natural enemies shown to maintain host shifts have always been from higher trophic levels, rather than competitors. 2. In Hawaii, an Australian parasitoid (Diachasmimorpha tryoni) of medflies that loses competition contests to a subsequently introduced Asian parasitoid (Fopius arisanus) has shifted its realised host range to attack non-target gall flies on lantana. 3. The present study demonstrates experimentally that D. tryoni reproduction is: (i) lower on medflies in coffee when F. arisanus is present than when it is absent; (ii) higher in gall flies on lantana than on medflies in coffee, when F. arisanus is present; and (iii) higher in medflies on coffee than in gall flies on lantana, when F. arisanus is absent. This meets Berdegue et al.'s (Ecological Entomology, 21, 203-217, 1996) three conditions to confirm the importance of enemy-free space. 4. In the field, F. arisanus is abundant on medflies, whereas D. tryoni is rare on medflies, but is the dominant parasitoid of lantana gall flies. 5. Competitor-free space is thus shown to be a key mechanism maintaining an apparent host shift by an introduced biocontrol agent onto a non-target species.