Comparison of RNA expression profiles based on maize expressed sequence tag frequency analysis and micro-array hybridization

Assembly of 73,000 expressed sequence tags (ESTs) representing multiple organs and developmental stages of maize (Zea mays) identified approximately 22,000 tentative unique genes (TUGs) at the criterion of 95% identity. Based on sequence similarity, overlap between any two of nine libraries with more than 3,000 ESTs ranged from 4%, to 20% of the constituent TUGs. The most abundant ESTs were recovered from only one or a minority of the libraries, and only 26 EST contigs had members from all nine EST sets (presumably representing ubiquitously expressed genes). For several examples, ESTs for different members of gene families were detected in distinct organs. To study this further, two types of micro-array slides were fabricated, one containing 5,534 ESTs from 10- to 14-d-old endosperm, and the other 4,844 ESTs from immature ear, estimated to represent about 2,800 and 2,500 unique genes, respectively. Each array type was hybridized with fluorescent cDNA targets prepared from endosperm and immature ear poly(A(+)) RNA. Although the 10- to 14-d-old postpollination endosperm TUGs showed only 12% overlap with immature ear TUGs, endosperm target hybridized with 94%, of the car TUGs, and ear target hybridized with 57% of the endosperm TUGs. Incomplete EST sampling of low-abundance transcripts contributes to an underestimate of shared gene expression profiles. Reassembly of ESTs at the criterion of 90% identity suggests how cross hybridization among gene family members can overestimate the overlap in genes expressed in micro-array hybridization experiments.