Pasture and forest soil microbial communities show distinct patterns in their catabolic respiration responses at a landscape scale

Catabolic responses to specific substrates can be used to differentiate soil microbial communities. We hypothesized that the catabolic respiration responses of microbial communities from pastures would differ from those of forest soils, and that the differences would be consistent at a landscape scale, due to inherent differences in litter quality and management regimes. We analysed respiration responses to 25 different substrates of 20 pasture soils (dominated by rye grass and white clover) and 20 forest soils (indigenous forest species or the plantation species Pinus radiata) over a wide geographical range in New Zealand. Within each pasture or forest category, the catabolic responses showed a similar pattern, suggesting similarities in functional catabolic capability and microbial community Indigenous forests and pine forests microbial communities did not differ in their responses. Pasture soil communities had significantly higher relative responses to carbohydrate and amino-acid substrates and significantly lower relative response to carboxylic acid substrates, than microbial communities from forest soils. Forest soils had relatively greater responses to carboxylic acids as a group, as well as citric acid, alpha-ketobutyric acid, alpha-ketoglutaric acid, and alpha-ketovaleric acid, than did the pasture soils. A subset of 6 substrates was equally as effective at differentiating the microbial catabolic response of pasture soils from forest soils as the entire set of 25 substrates. The results demonstrated distinct differences in the respiration responses of the soil microbial communities of pastures and forests, but showed strong similarities within each vegetation class, despite the wide geographical spread, different soils and plant species. (C) 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.