Risk of invasive cervical cancer after pap smears: the protective effect of multiple negatives

Objective: To determine the relationship between the number of initial negative Pap smears and risk of subsequent cervical cancer. Design: A cohort study was conducted using data from the British Columbia Cervical Cancer Screening Program and British Columbia Cancer Registry. The analysis used a random sample (1%) of women aged 20-69 with Pap smears and all cases of invasive cervical cancer diagnosed between 1994 and 1999. Each negative screen defined the beginning of a screening interval and intervals longer than five years were truncated. The following variables were created for each interval: age at the beginning of the interval, interval length, previous cytological abnormality, previous cervical procedure and number of preceding consecutive negative screens. The relationship between these variables and risk of squamous cervical cancer was determined using survival analysis methods. Results: A total of 388 cases of invasive cervical cancer (252 squamous) were included in the study from a study population of over 3.3 million Pap smears. The risk of invasive squamous cancer increased with time since the lost negative screen, history of cytological abnormality and history of cervical therapeutic procedure. Risk was not significantly related to age (P=0.2) but was highest in women aged 30-49. Multiple consecutive negative pap smears were associated with reduced risk in women with a history of moderate atypia (P < 0.0001), but not in women without a history (P=0.4). Conclusions: Multiple consecutive negative cytology was not associated with reduced risk of invasive cervical cancer in women with no history of cytological abnormality.