Stereochemistry of the enolization of scytalone by scytalone dehydratase

In D2O, scytalone exchanges its two C2 hydrogen atoms for deuterium atoms at different rates. Al pD 7.0 and 25 degrees C, half-lives for the exchanges are 0.8 and 10 days for the pro-S and pro-R hydrogens, respectively. The differential exchange rates allow for the preparation of multiple scytalone samples (through incubation of scytalone in D2O and then back exchanging with H2O) having differential levels of deuterium enrichment at the C2 pro-S and pro-R positions. From these samples, the stereochemical preference for hydrogen abstraction during the dehydration reaction mediated by the enzyme scytalone dehydratase was determined. At pH 7.0, deuterium at the pro-S position has little effect on enzyme catalysis, whereas deuterium at the pro-R position produces kinetic isotope effects of 2.3 (25 degrees C), 5.1 (25 degrees C), and 6.7 (6.8 degrees C) on k(cat), k(cat)/K-m, and the single-turnover rate, respectively. The results are fully consistent with the enzyme catalyzing a syn elimination through an E1cb-like mechanism. The syn elimination is compatible with the interactions realized between a scytalone boat conformation and key active site residues as modeled from multiple X-ray crystal structures of the enzyme in complexes with inhibitors.