13Carbon urea breath test is not as accurate as endoscopy to detect Helicobacter pylori after gastrectomy

Background: This study was conducted to determine (1) whether Helicobacter pylori infection decreases in conjunction with time elapsed after gastrectomy and (2) the diagnostic efficacy of C-13 urea breath test (UBT) for H pylori in patients after gastrectomy. Methods: From January 1997 to June 1998, 86 patients who had undergone gastrectomy and 180 patients with dyspepsia without gastrectomy were enrolled. A UBT for the analysis of excess (CO2)-C-13/(CO2)-C-12 ratio (ECR) was obtained for each patient. Each patient also underwent endoscopy to obtain gastric biopsies for histology and H pylori culture. The presence of H pylori by either histology or culture served as the standard to test the efficacy of UBT. The 86 patients with a prior gastrectomy were categorized into 3 subgroups (I, less than 1 year; II, 1 to 3 years; III, greater than 3 years), according to the interval between surgery and UBT. The initial H pylori status of these 86 patients was determined by histologic evaluation of the resected stomach. Results: At trial initiation, the postgastrectomy group had a lower H pylori infection rate (52.3%) as compared with the dyspeptic control group (80%). The initial H pylori status among subgroups I, II, and III was similar. There was a trend for the presence of H pylori in the stomach to decrease with increasing time elapsed after surgery (I to III: 68.8%, 48.3%, 36%, respectively; p < 0.05). The maximum UBT sensitivity and specificity achieved were 82.2% and 87.8% in the gastrectomy group and 97.2% and 96.3% in the dyspeptic group, with cutoff points of 2.5 and 4.0, respectively. Conclusion: The prevalence of H pylori diminishes with time elapsed after gastrectomy. UBT for detection of H pylori is more effective in patients without prior gastrectomy than in patients who have undergone gastrectomy and is less effective than endoscopy for patients who have had a gastrectomy.