Shading enhances the quality of willow leaves to leaf beetles - but does it matter?

Plant shading is commonly recognised as a factor, which increases susceptibility of plants to attack by herbivorous insects. In this study we experimentally investigated the effect of host plant shading on two willow-feeding leaf beetles, Galerucella lineola feeding upon Salix phylicifolia and Phratora, vitellinae feeding upon Salix myrsinifolia. Both beetle species were more abundant on potted willows growing in open habitats than on the same clones placed under the shade of trees. However, in the laboratory the food preference by adults and larval performance showed that the shaded willows are actually better food fur both beetle species. On the contrary, when larvae were reared in the field under natural abiotic conditions, we found no difference in larval performance, or if any, even better performance in open habitats. Apparently. higher and more variable daily temperatures in open habitats accelerated the growth of the larvae. When adults were let to emigrate from or immigrate to potted willows, which had been grown in the same conditions but placed either in the open or shady habitats, adults preferred exposed willows. Invertebrate predators were more abundant in open habitats, but we found no differences in lear beetle mortality by natural enemies between the habitats. Although the larval performance appeared to be approximately equal in the two habitats during the unusually warm study period, we suggest that under suboptimal temperatures the better abiotic conditions of open sites can easily override the better food provided by shaded habitats. The selection of abiotic habitat thus plays a significant role in the adaptive habitat and host plant selection of these beetles within the gradient of shadiness.