Inter- and intraspecific relationships between shade tolerance and shade avoidance in temperate trees

Patterns of physiological and architectural adaptation and acclimation to decreasing light availability were investigated along a light gradient for saplings of 12 common species of temperate deciduous trees in southeastern Ontario, Canada. Physiological adaptation and acclimation (shade tolerance physiology) were quantified at the leaf level by measuring leaf mass per unit area (LIVIA), dark respiration per unit leaf nitrogen, chlorophyll par unit leaf nitrogen and the chlorophyll a:b ratio for the newest fully expanded leaf on the leader. Architectural adaptation and acclimation (shade avoidance) were quantified by measuring branching intensity and side shoot:main shoot length ratios for the most recent three years of growth on the leader and selected side branches. Within species, increases in LMA, chlorophyll a:b ratio and respiration per unit nitrogen and decreases in chlorophyll per unit nitrogen indicated that shade tolerance physiology generally increased with decreasing canopy openness. increases in the branching intensity and side shoot:main shoot ratios of the leader and side branches indicated that shade avoidance also increased with decreasing canopy openness for the majority of species; however, in some species, stem bending under deep shade resulted in lateral growth. Interspecific variation in shade tolerance physiology was minimal when species were compared under equal amounts of canopy openness. Tn contrast, interspecific variation in shade avoidance variables was relatively high under equal canopy openness, with saplings of shade tolerant canopy species exhibiting higher shade avoidance than saplings of shade tolerant understory species.