A critique of the recovery of greenback cutthroat trout

There are no examples of recovery of fish listed under the US. Endangered Species Act, but the number of federally threatened greenback cutthroat trout (Oncorhynchus clarki stomias) populations is approaching the delisting goal We evaluated recovery of this subspecies in light of developing theory in conservation biology and with regard to recovery of other salmonids in the inland western United States. Four of the five criteria used to define populations that would count toward delisting appeared to underestimate the risk of extinction of those populations. Typically, recovery goals for numbers of greenback cutthroat trout populations were less stringent than those for other inland salmonids petitioned for listing or listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act and were comparable to those for a federally endangered species. Before delisting is considered, we propose that historical populations be replicated in additional waters to protect genetic diversity and that existing populations be enlarged to reduce their vulnerability to demographic variation, to increase their access to refugia, and to permit reestablishment of mobile life histories, Existing stocks should also be evaluated to determine whether they represent distinct population segments.