Stress test criteria used in the conservative arm of the FRISC-II trial underdetects surgical coronary artery disease when applied to patients in the VANQWISH trial

OBJECTIVES We sought to determine whether the stringent stress test criteria for crossover to cardiac catheterization in the conservative arm of the Fast Revascularization During Instability in Coronary Artery, Disease (FRISC-II) trial subjected this strategy., to a disadvantage by failing to identify patients with surgical coronary artery disease (CAD). BACKGROUND In FRISC-II, an invasive strategy provided superior outcomes compared with a conservative strategy for patients with acute coronary syndromes. However, compared with the stress test criteria for crossover to catheterization in the Veterans Affairs Non-Q-Wave Infarction Strategies in Hospital (VANQWISH) trial, the FRISC-II criteria were more restrictive and did not use nuclear imaging or pharmacologic stress testing. METHODS We analyzed the conservative arm of VANQWISH to identify the prevalence of surgical CAD in those patients who met the VANQWISH, but not FRISC-II, criteria for catheterization. RESULTS Of 385 VANQWISH patients, 90 (23%) met the FRISC-II criteria for catheterization. Another 98 patients (25%) met only VANQWISH stress test criteria (60 patients by exercise and 38 by pharmacologic nuclear stress testing). Among subjects who underwent pre discharge angiography, those meeting only VANQWISH stress test criteria had a high prevalence of surgical CAD (51%), comparable to patients who met FRISC-II criteria (54%, p = 0.805). CONCLUSIONS The overly stringent risk stratification protocol for conservative-arm patients in FRISC-II could have failed to identify almost as many patients with surgical CAD as it identified. A lower threshold for catheterization in the FRISC-II conservative patients might have improved their outcomes and therefore diminished the putative benefit of an invasive strategy. (J Am Coll Cardiol 2002;39:1601-7) (C) 2002 by the American College of Cardiology Foundation.