Surgery and permanent 125I seed paraspinal bracaytherapy for malignant tumors with spinal cord compression

Purpose: To evaluate the functional outcome, predictors of response, and toxicity from spinal surgery and I-125 brachytherapy in patients with malignant tumors resulting in spinal cord compression. Methods and Materials: Between July 1985 and September 2001, after surgical resection, 30 patients underwent 31 intraoperative paraspinal brachytherapy procedures at Barrow Neurological Institute. Twenty-four (with 25 procedures) had follow-up at our clinic and form the basis for this report. Surgical procedures were based on the location of the impinging lesion: corpectomy or spondylectomy in 13 cases and laminectomy in 12. Permanent I-125 seeds in absorbable suture were placed with open exposure after resection. Results: Spinal cord compression was cervical in 4 (16%), thoracic in 14 (56%), and lumbar in 7 (28%) of the 25 cases. One patient underwent two separate procedures at different spinal sites. Of the 25 brachytherapy sites, 22 also received external beam radiotherapy (EBRT): 5, EBRT with a planned brachytherapy boost; 4, brachytherapy and prompt EBRT after recovery; and 13, brachytherapy as salvage for local failure after prior EBRT. Three had no EBRT: 1 had lymphoma treated with chemotherapy, 1 had remote previous EBRT for a childhood tumor, and 1 refused EBRT. The mean follow-up was 19.8 months. The 2- and 3-year actuarial local control rate was 87.4% and 72.9%, respectively. Four sites (16.0%) experienced local failure. The mean time to recurrence for these 4 patients was 20.3 months. Three of the four had failed prior EBRT, with surgery and brachytherapy used for salvage. The 2- and 3-year actuarial overall survival rates were 24.0% and 16.0%, mean 19.2 months. An ambulatory function score was assigned pre- and postoperatively: 1, normal ambulation; 11, abnormal not requiring assistance; III, abnormal requiring assistance; and IV, unable to ambulate. All patients with score 1, 91 % of those with score 11, 67 % of those with score III, and 67 % of those with score IV were ambulatory after the procedure; 84% had either normal or improved ambulation postoperatively. Morbidity was restricted to four postoperative events: one cerebrospinal fluid leak, two wound infections treated in situ without removal of seeds or instrumentation, and one pulmonary embolus. No myelopathies or other neurologic sequelae were encountered. Conclusion: This is the largest series in the literature exploring surgery and I-125 brachytherapy in the treatment of malignant spinal cord compression. We found this to be well tolerated and to result in durable local control and ambulatory function. Our results suggest a benefit to aggressive local therapy in selected patients with spinal cord compression. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science Inc.