Influence of mesh materials on collagen deposition in a rat model

Alterations of the extracellular matrix (ECM) with its major component collagen are increasingly discussed as possible risk factors implicated in the development of abdominal-wall herniation. Because of the widespread use of alloplastic meshes for the surgical repair of hernias, an animal study was performed to analyze the influence of various mesh materials on the quantity and quality of collagen deposition. In 60 male Sprague-Dawley rats an abdominal replacement was performed using three different kinds of mesh materials: polyester (PE), a pure polypropylene (PP), and a composite mesh made of polypropylene and polyglactin (PG). A simple fascia suture repair served as control. The count of fibroblasts, the collagen/protein ratio, the type I/III collagen ratio, and the ex-pression of basic fibroblast growth factor (b-FGF) at the interface were analyzed after 7, 21, and 90 days. The ratio of collagen to overall protein (mug/mg) showed significant differences comparing different mesh materials (sham controls 38.44 +/- 16.33 mug/mg, PE 68.5 +/- 23.8 mug/mg, PP 101.6 +/- 32.3 mug/mg, PG 49.6 +/- 11.6 mug/mg at day 90). The ratio of Collagen type I/III increased over time in all groups. However, 90 days after mesh implantation the ratio was always significantly lowered compared to the controls. No significant difference was found comparing different mesh materials. The alteration of the scar composition is closely connected to an increased b-FGF expression. b-FGF and count of fibroblasts highly correlated (r = .95) and showed significant elevated levels compared to simple suture repair. The results of our study strongly support the notion that wound healing is affected by mesh implantation. The quality of the ECM deposition as determined by collagen type I/III ratio is impaired in general, whereas the quantity of ECM deposition is markedly influenced by the kind of mesh material.