Preparation of a stable double emulsion (W1/O/W2):: role of the interfacial films on the stability of the system

This paper presents new protocols enabling preparation of W-1/O/W-2 double emulsions: one, using soybean oil as the O phase, that yields edible emulsions with industrial applications, and a second that yields emulsions with a previously unattainable concentration 15% (w/w) of surfactants in the external phase (the 15% target was chosen to meet the typical industry standard). Preparation of a stable W-1/O emulsion was found to be critical for the stability of the system as a whole. Of the various low HLB primary surfactants tested, only cethyl dimethicone copolyol (Abil EM90(R)), A-B-A block copolymer (Arlacel P135(R)), and polyglycerol ester of ricinoleic acid (Grinstead PGR-90(R)) yielded a stable W/O emulsion. Investigation of the surface properties of those surfactants using the monolayer technique found two significant similarities: (1) stable, compressible, and reversibly expandable monolayers; and (2) high elasticity and surface potential. The high degree of elasticity of the interfacial film between W-1 and O makes it highly resilient under stress; its failure to break contributes to the stability of the emulsion. The high surface potential values observed suggest that the surfactant molecules lie flat at the O/W interfaces. In particular, in the case of PGR-90, the hydroxyl (-OH) groups on the fatty acid chains serve as anchors at the O/W interfaces and are responsible for the high surface potential. The long-term stability of the double emulsion requires a balance between the Laplace and osmotic pressures (between W-1 droplets in O and between W-1 droplets and the external aqueous phase W-2). The presence of a thickener in the outer phase is necessary in order to reach a viscosity ratio (preferably approximately 1) between the W-1/O and W-2 phases, allowing dispersion of the viscous primary emulsion into the W-2 aqueous phase. The thickener, which also serves as a dispersant and consequently prevents phase separation due to its thixotropic properties, must be compatible with the surfactants. Finally, the interactions between the low and high HLB emulsifiers at the O/W-2 interface should not destabilize the films. It was observed that such destructive interaction for the system could be prevented by the use of two high HLB surfactants in the outer aqueous phase: an amphoteric surfactant, Betaine, and an anionic surfactant, sodium lauryl ether sulfate. The combination of such pairs of surfactants was found to contribute to the films' stability. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.