Comparing biological effects and potencies of estrone and 17β-estradiol in mature fathead minnows, Pimephales promelas

The presence of endocrine active compounds such as estrogens in treated wastewater effluent and their effects on aquatic life are causing concern among aquatic resource managers. In contrast to 17 beta-estradiol (E2), the steroid hormone produced by all vertebrates, the biological effects of estrone (El), one of its breakdown products are less understood, even though the aquatic concentrations of El are often higher than those of E2. The central hypothesis of this study was that at environmental concentrations, El has estrogenic effects in fish, with increased vitellogenin concentrations and decreased reproductive success in both male and female fathead minnows, as found with E2. In two replicate experiments, we exposed mature fathead minnows to three concentrations of each estrogen for 21 days in a flow-through exposure system and measured a broad suite of anatomical (body indices, histopathology), physiological (plasma vitellogenin), behavioral (nest defense), and reproductive (fecundity, fertility, hatching) endpoints. These endpoints have previously been associated with adverse effects of estrogenic exposures. While body length and weight parameters were unaltered by exposure, secondary sex characteristics exhibited an exposure concentrated-related decline in male fathead minnows. Interestingly, low concentrations of estrone (similar to 15 ng/L) enhanced the aggressiveness of male fathead minnows in a behavioral assay. Vitellogenin concentrations in male fish increased with higher concentrations of both estrogens, but remained unchanged in all female treatments. A decrease in fecundity was observed at high concentrations of E2 as compared with control minnows. These results suggest that El, at concentrations previously found in waters receiving wastewater effluent, can have reproductive effects on fish. (C) 2011 Elsevier BM. All rights reserved.