Raffles, roles, and the outcome of sperm competition in sockeye salmon

In species with male alternative reproductive phenotypes, one phenotype is usually disadvantaged in mating competition. In salmonid fishes, large late-maturing males pair with nesting females and maintain close contact before and during spawning. Small early-maturing males have little contact with nesting females and, during spawning, begin to release sperm after the paired male. The effects of male phenotype and timing of ejaculation on success in sperm competition are not known. In this study, we determined paternity of offspring resulting from in vitro competitive fertilizations to examine these two aspects of sperm competition in sockeye salmon, Oncorhynchus nerka (Walbaum, 1792). When we fertilized eggs with mixtures of equal numbers of sperm from each of two male age classes, we found that success in sperm competition did not depend on male age. However, success in these competitive fertilizations did not conform to the fair raffle model of sperm competition, since paternity in most of the clutches was biased in favour of one male. When we added milt from two males sequentially to a batch of eggs, we found that sperm from the second male fertilized fewer eggs than sperm from the first male, but the difference was less than expected. In addition, a male's success when his milt was added first was not correlated with his success when his milt was added second.