Vertical structure and predator refuge mediate oyster reef development and community dynamics

In addition to their economic value, oysters supply a number of critical ecosystem services such as controlling eutrophication, recycling nutrients, and providing habitat for many invertebrates and fishes. Thus, the maintenance and restoration of oyster reefs is vital for properly functioning estuarine ecosystems. We hypothesized that spatially heterogeneous and refuge-rich reefs are superior habitats for oysters and associated invertebrates and fishes. If this is shown to be the case, then vertical structure and refuge should be included in the design of newly constructed oyster reefs and conserved in existing reefs. To test our hypothesis, models were built as concrete blocks into which shells were placed horizontally, vertically, and widely spaced, and vertically and closely spaced. Respectively, the units represent horizontal orientation with no refuge (HNR), vertical orientation with no refuge (VNR), and vertical orientation with refuge (VWR). Flume studies of velocity distributions over each model type showed distinctive differences that may contribute to differential settlement on the models in the absence of predators or sediment. A subsequent settlement study in the same flume showed significantly higher settlement densities to horizontal shells than to vertical shells regardless of refuge (HNR>VNR=VWR). This result indicates the primary importance of settlement surface orientation (horizontal vs. vertical) over predation refuge when predators are absent. In contrast, two field recruitment studies indicated that the importance of orientation relative to predation refuge might depend on sedimentation rates. When sedimentation was low, the number of oysters and barnacles (live, dead, and total) was significantly higher on no-refuge models than on refuge models (HNR=VNR>VWR). However, percent mortality was lower on the refuge models than on the no refuge models (HNR=VNR>VWR). This leads to a conclusion that although fewer oysters may settle on refuge shells, those that do have a higher rate of survival. In a year when sedimentation was high, recruitment and survival of oysters, barnacles, and bryozoans was higher on vertical models regardless of refuge. In aggregate, our results indicate that both vertical orientation and predation refuge are critical to the early development of the oyster reef community and should be included in restoration designs. (C) 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.