Coronal shocks of November 1997 revisited: The Cme-type II timing problem

We re-examine observations bearing on the origin of metric type II bursts for six impulsive solar events in November 1997. Previous analyses of these events indicated that the metric type IIs were due to flares ( either blast waves or ejecta). Our point of departure was the study of Zhang et al. ( 2001) based on the Large Angle and Spectrometric Coronagraph's C1 instrument ( occulting disk at 1.1 R-0) that identified the rapid acceleration phase of coronal mass ejections (CMEs) with the rise phase of soft X-ray light curves of associated flares. We find that the inferred onset of rapid CME acceleration in each of the six cases occurred 1 - 3 min before the onset of metric type II emission, in contrast to the results of previous studies for certain of these events that obtained CME launch times similar to 25 - 45 min earlier than type II onset. The removal of the CME-metric type II timing discrepancy in these events and, more generally, the identification of the onset of the rapid acceleration phase of CMEs with the flare impulsive phase undercuts a significant argument against CMEs as metric type II shock drivers. In general, the six events exhibited: ( 1) ample evidence of dynamic behavior [ soft X-ray ejecta, extreme ultra-violet imaging telescope (EIT) dimming onsets, and wave initiation ( observed variously in H alpha, EUV, and soft X-rays)] during the inferred fast acceleration phases of the CMEs, consistent with the cataclysmic disruption of the low solar atmosphere one would expect to be associated with a CME; and ( 2) an organic relationship between EIT dimmings ( generally taken to be source regions of CMEs) and EIT waves ( which are highly associated with metric type II bursts) indicative of a CME-driver scenario. Our analysis indicates that the broad (similar to 90 degrees to halo) CMEs observed in the outer LASCO coronagraphs for these impulsive events began life as relatively small-scale structures, with angular spans of similar to 15 degrees in the low corona. A review of on-going work bearing on other aspects ( than timing) of the question of the origin of metric type II bursts ( CME association; connectivity of metric and decametric-hectometric type II shocks; spatial relationship between CMEs and metric shocks) leads to the conclusion that CMEs remain a strong candidate to be the principal/sole driver of metric type II shocks vis-a-vis flare blast waves/ejecta.