Structure-activity considerations and in vitro approaches to assess the genotoxicity of 19 methane-, benzene- and toluenesulfonic acid esters

Sulfonic acid esters are considered as potentially alkylating agents that may exert genotoxic effects in bacterial and mammalian cell systems. One possible source of human exposure stems from drug synthesis when the salt-forming agents methanesulfonic acid, benzenesulfonic acid or p-toluenesulfonic acid are used together with alcoholic solvents such as methanol, ethanol and propanol. In this study computer-assisted structural considerations and in vitro approaches (Ames mutagenicity test using Salmonella typhimurium strains TA98 and TA 100, and the micronucleus test using L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells) were used to assess the genotoxic properties of 19 sulfonic esters. While all esters may be principally active as genotoxicants based on the presence of the sulfonate moiety, the statistical correlative multiple computer automated structure evaluation (MCASE) system (MC4PC version 1.0) using the Ames mutagenicity A2I module (version 1.54), rank-ordered the activity of the benzenesulfonic acid esters in the Ames test negligible due to an inactivating modulator and a deactivating fragment, whereas the methane- and toluenesulfonic acid esters were predicted to be positive in this test. In the Ames test, with the exception of the p-toluenesulfonic acid ethyl and iso-butyl esters, all compounds came out positive in Salmonella strain TA100. Methanesulfonic iso-propyl, sec-butyl and benzenesulfonic acid iso-propyl ester also showed mutagenic potential in strain TA98. In general, differences between results seen in Ames tests performed with or without metabolic activation were rather small. In L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells, benzenesulfonic acid n- and iso-butyl ester and p-toluenesulfonic acid iso-butyl ester did not increase the number of cells containing micronuclei. The other esters were positive in this micronucleus test; however, methanesulfonic acid iso-butyl ester was found to be only weakly positive at excessively cytotoxic concentrations. These compounds were generally found to be more potent with regard to micronucleus induction when tested without metabolic activation (20 h treatment). In conclusion, the iso-propyl esters of the three sulfonic acids under study were found to be the strongest mutagens, either when tested in the Ames test or the micronucleus assay, whereas p-toluenesulfonic acid iso-butyl ester was the only compound shown to be devoid of a genotoxic potential in both tests. (c) 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.