Specificity in induced plant responses shapes patterns of herbivore occurrence on Solanum dulcamara

Interspecific competition between phytophagous insects can occur when plant responses induced by an early-season herbivore alter host quality for later colonizers. Recent evidence for specificity in the elicitation of induced plant responses by different attackers suggests that dynamics of host use in the field may be more complex than previously anticipated, because host suitability for colonizing herbivores may depend on which herbivore species has initially damaged a plant. In each of two years, we manipulated the first herbivore to attack Solanum dulcainara plants in an experimental population using several different arthropod species and subsequently monitored colonization by natural herbivores over the course of the growing season. We additionally performed weekly herbivore counts in wild S. dulcamara populations following natural variation in herbivore arrival. Plant-mediated interactions occurred primarily between two leaf-feeding beetles, Psylliodes qffinis and Plagiometriona clovata. In both manipulatiye and observational experiments, P. clavata oviposition was reduced on plants initially damaged by P. affinis (or a third leaf-feeding beetle, Lema trilinea) relative to plants that were initially undamaged. Lowored P. clavata occurrence continued through subsequent life-history stages, resulting in decreased emergence of second-generation P. clavata adults on these plants. The occurrence of P. affinis was also lowered on plants damaged by conspecifics in both manipulative and observational experiments. Resistance against P. qffinis also followed applications of jasmonic acid, an elicitor of plant defensive responses. Conversely, early-season damage by P. clavata did not influence plant quality for either later conspecifics or P. affinis. Initial herbivory by the spittlebug Aphrophora saratogensis or generalist taildropper slugs (Prophysaon sp.) likewise had no influence on P. clavata and P. qffinis colonization, whereas L. trilinea damage did not affect later arriving P. affinis. Hence, only a subset of early-season damagers influenced herbivore occurrence on S. dulcamara. Preference tests examining P. affinis feeding and P. clavata oviposition confirmed that specificity in elicitation of induced plant responses produced the divergent herbivore occurrence patterns observed in the field. Overall, the existence of plant-mediated competitive asymmetry between herbivore species on S. duleamara highlights the dynamic nature of plant resistance and its potential role in organizing herbivore communities.