Clear-fell harvest impacts on biodiversity: past research and the search for harvest size thresholds

Clear-fell harvesting has large aesthetic impacts and significantly alters ecosystem attributes at multiple spatial scales. Known abiotic changes include increased microclimatic variability, changes in regional water balance, and modified hydrological patterns that influence erosion processes. Biotic changes include increased species richness immediately post-clear-felling due to shifts in species composition resulting from changes in individual species abundance and colonization by disturbance-adapted or open-habitat species. Given the large ecological changes caused by clear-fell harvesting and the negative public perception of clear-felling. it is surprising that few studies have investigated whether reducing clear-fell harvest area may be a viable strategy to mitigate ecological change within individual clearcuts. Clear-fell size studies conducted to date rarely exceed a maximum harvest area of 10 ha, and biotic communities measured exhibit mixed responses with respect to species richness and other biodiversity attributes with increasing clear-fell size. Some postharvest ecological responses are nonlinear with respect to harvest area and suggest possible threshold sizes beyond which clear-fell impacts increase disproportionately to their size. Conceptual models of potential ecological thresholds in clear-fell harvest impacts are discussed, as is the need for rigorous empirical testing to ensure a solid foundation exists for forest harvesting guidelines.