From terrestrial to aquatic habitats and back again - molecular insights into the evolution and phylogeny of Hydrophiloidea (Coleoptera) using multigene analyses

The phylogenetic relationships within Hydrophiloidea have been a matter of controversial discussion for many years and the supposedly repeated changes between aquatic and terrestrial lifestyles are not well understood. In order to address these issues we used an extensive molecular data set comprising sequences from six nuclear and mitochondrial genes. The analyses accomplished with the entire data set resulted in largely congruent tree topologies concerning the main branches, independent from the analytical procedures. However, only Bayesian analyses yielded sufficient high posterior probabilities, whereas bootstrap support values for most nodes were generally low. Our results are only partially congruent with hypotheses based on morphological analyses. Spercheidae were placed as the sister group of the remaining hydrophiloid subgroups. Hydrophiloidea excluding Spercheidae split into two clades: the 'helophorid lineage' comprising the small groups Epimetopidae, Hydrochidae, Georissidae and Helophoridae, and the largest family, Hydrophilidae. Within Hydrophilidae, Hydrophilinae do not form a monophylum. The predominantly terrestrial Sphaeridiinae were placed as a subordinate clade within this subfamily. Furthermore, our data suggest a single origin of the aquatic lifestyle in Hydrophiloidea, with numerous secondary changes to terrestrial habits and tertiary changes to aquatic habitats within Sphaeridiinae.