Comparison of spatial variation in otolith chemistry of two fish species and relationships with water chemistry and otolith growth

Spatial variation in the chemistry (Mg, Mn, Sr and Ba) of recently deposited otolith material (last 20-30 days of life) was compared between two demersal fish species; snapper Pagrus auratus (Sparidae) and sand flathead Platycephalus bassensis (Platycephalidae), that were collected simultaneously at 12 sites across three bays in Victoria, south-eastern Australia. Otolith chemistry was also compared with ambient water chemistry and among three sampling positions adjacent to the proximal otolith margin. For both species, variation in otolith chemistry among bays was significant for Ba, Mn and Sr; however, differences among bays were only similar between species for Ba and Mn. Only Ba showed significant variation at the site level. Across the 12 sites, mean otolith Ba levels were significantly positively correlated between species. Further, although incorporation rates differed, mean ambient Ba levels for both species were positively correlated with ambient Ba levels. Spatial variation in multi-element otolith chemistry was also broadly similar between species and with multi-element water chemistry. Partition coefficients clearly indicated species-specific incorporation of elements into otoliths. Mg and Mn were consistently higher in snapper than sand flathead otoliths (mean +/- S.D., Mg snapper 22.1 +/- 3.8 and sand flathead 9.9 +/- 1.5 mu g g(-1), Mn snapper 4.4 +/- 2.6 and sand flathead 0.5 +/- 0.3 mu g g(-1)), Sr was generally higher in sand flathead otoliths (sand flathead 1570 +/- 235 and snapper 1346 +/- 104 mu g g(-1)) and Ba was generally higher in snapper otoliths (snapper 12.1 +/- 12.8 and sand flathead 1.8 +/- 1.4 mu g g(-1)). For both species, Mg and Mn were higher in the faster accreting regions of the otolith margin, Sr was lower in the slower accreting region and Ba showed negligible variation among the three sampling regions. This pattern was consistent with the higher Mg and Mn, and generally lower Sr observed in the faster accreting snapper otoliths. It is hypothesized that the differences between species in the incorporation of these elements may be at least partly related to differences in metabolic and otolith accretion rate. Although rates of elemental incorporation into otoliths appear species specific, for elements such as Ba where incorporation appears consistently related to ambient concentrations, spatial variation in otolith chemistry should show similarity among co-occurring species. (c) 2007 The Authors.