Mechanisms underlying the antifibrotic properties of noninhibitory PAI-1 (PAI-1R) in experimental nephritis

Huang Y, Border WA, Lawrence DA, Noble NA. Mechanisms underlying the antifibrotic properties of noninhibitory PAI-1 (PAI-1R) in experimental nephritis. Am J Physiol Renal Physiol 297: F1045-F1054, 2009. First published July 22, 2009; doi:10.1152/ajprenal. 00024.2009.-Administration of a mutant, noninhibitory PAI-1 (PAI-1R), reduces disease in experimental glomerulonephritis. Here we investigated the importance of vitronectin (Vn) binding, PAI-1 stability and protease binding in this therapeutic effect using a panel of PAI-1 mutants differing in half-life, protease binding, and Vn binding. PAI-1R binds Vn normally but does not inhibit proteases. PAI-1AK has a complete defect in Vn binding but retains full inhibitory activity, with a short half-life similar to wild-type (wt)-PAI-1. Mutant 14-1b is identical to wt-PAI-1 but with a longer half-life. PAI-1K has defective Vn binding, inhibits proteases normally, and has a long half-life. In vitro wt-PAI-1 dramatically inhibited degradation of mesangial cell ECM while the AK mutant had much less effect. Mutants 14-1b and PAI-1K, like wt-PAI-1, inhibited matrix degradation but PAI-1R failed to reverse this inhibition although PAI-1R reversed the wt-PAI-1-induced inhibition of ECM degradation in a plasmin-, time-, and dose-dependent manner. Thus the ability of PAI-1 to inhibit ECM degradation is dependent both on its antiproteinase activity and on maintaining an active conformation achieved either by Vn binding or mutation to a stable form. Administration of these PAI-1 mutants to nephritic rats confirmed the in vitro data; only PAI-1R showed therapeutic effects. PAI-1K did not bind to nephritic kidney, indicating that Vn binding is essential to the therapeutic action of PAI-1R. The ability of PAI-1R to remain bound to Vn even in a high-protease environment is very likely the key to its therapeutic efficacy. Furthermore, because both PAI-1R and 14-1b bound to the nephritic kidney in the same pattern and differ only in their ability to bind proteases, lack of protease inhibition is also keyed to PAI-1R's therapeutic action.