Race, Gender, and the Black Women's Standpoint

Hill Collins (1997, 1998, 2000) argues that because of their position within the intersecting hierarchies of race, gender, and class, black women as a group possess a unique angle of vision on the social world. Rooted in the everyday experiences of black women, the black women's standpoint is marked by an intersectional understanding of oppression and a legacy of struggle against such oppression. In this article, I employ quantitative analyses of data from the National Survey of Black Americans (1992) and the National Black Feminist Study (2004-2005) to investigate the black women's standpoint. I ask: Do black women as a group tend toward the black women's standpoint that Hill Collins describes? and Do black women embrace this perspective more than black men? Results from numerous chi 2 and logistic regression analyses suggest that, within the black community, gender is not a significant predictor of the standpoint that Hill Collins describes, with black men and black women being equally likely to embrace many of the core ideas associated with the black women's standpoint. I conclude by discussing the implications of this finding for gender and race-based standpoint theory.