The Emergence of Anion-π Catalysis

CONSPECTUS: The objective of this Account is to summarize the first five years of anion-pi catalysis. The general idea of anion-pi catalysis is to stabilize anionic transition states on aromatic surfaces. This is complementary to the stabilization of cationic transition states on aromatic surfaces, a mode of action that occurs in nature and is increasingly used in chemistry. Anion-pi catalysis, however, rarely occurs in nature and has been unexplored in chemistry. Probably because the attraction of anions to pi surfaces as such is counterintuitive, anion-pi interactions in general are much younger than cation-pi interactions and remain under recognized until today. Anion-pi catalysis has emerged from early findings that anion-pi interactions can mediate the transport of anions across lipid bilayer membranes. With this evidence for stabilization in the ground state secured, there was no reason to believe that anion-pi interactions could not also stabilize anionic transition states. As an attractive reaction to develop anion-pi catalysis, the addition of malonic acid half thioesters to enolate acceptors was selected. This choice was also made because without enzymes decarboxylation is preferred and anion-pi interactions promised to catalyze selectively the disfavored but relevant enolate addition. Concerning anion-pi catalysts, we started with naphthalene diimides (NDIs) because their intrinsic quadrupole moment is highly positive. The NDI scaffold was used to address questions such as the positioning of substrates on the catalytic pi surface or the dependence of activity on the pi-acidity of this pi surface. With the basics in place, the next milestone was the creation of anion-pi enzymes, that is, enzymes that operate with an interaction rarely used in biology, at least on intrinsically pi-acidic or highly polarizable aromatic amino-acid side chains. Electric-field-assisted anion-pi catalysis addresses topics such as heterogeneous catalysis on electrodes and remote control of activity by voltage. On pi-stacked foldamers, anion-(pi),-pi catalysis was discovered. Fullerenes emerged as the scaffold of choice to explore contributions from polarizability. On fullerenes, anionic transition states are stabilized by large macrodipoles that appear only in response to their presence. With this growing collection of anion-pi catalysts, several reactions beyond enolate addition have been explored so far. Initial efforts focused on asymmetric anion-pi catalysis. Increasing enantioselectivity with increasing pi acidity of the active pi surface has been exemplified for enamine and iminium chemistry and for anion-pi transaminase mimics. However, the delocalized nature of anion-pi interactions calls for the stabilization of charge displacements over longer distances. The first step in this direction was the formation of cyclohexane rings with five stereogenic centers from achiral acyclic substrates on pi-acidic surfaces. Moreover, the intrinsically disfavored exo transition state of anionic Diels Alder reactions is stabilized selectively on pi-acidic surfaces; endo products and otherwise preferred Michael addition products are completely suppressed. Taken together, we hope that these results on catalyst design and reaction scope will establish anion-pi catalysis as a general principle in catalysis in the broadest sense.