Calibration between temperature and Mg/Ca and oxygen isotope ratios in high-magnesium calcite tests of asexually reproduced juveniles of large benthic foraminifers

Mg/Ca ratios and oxygen isotope ratios (delta O-18) in biogenic high-magnesium calcite tests precipitated by reef dwelling large benthic foraminifers can be used as paleotemperature proxies because they correlated well with the temperature of seawater. However, it is still unclear whether there is an interspecies difference in temperature correlation among several perforate and imperforate species. We used four species of large benthic foraminifers to perform culture experiments at controlled temperatures (21-31 degrees C). Neorotalia calcar, Baculogypsina sphaerulata, and Calcarina gaudichaudii were selected as the perforate species, whereas Amphisorus kudakajimensis was chosen as the imperforate species. The data obtained by analyses suggest linear relations between Mg/Ca and temperature except at 31 degrees C, and also in the case of A. kudakajimensis except at 29 degrees C, which is likely caused by thermal stress resulting in metabolic anomaly in the foraminifers. Furthermore, A. kudakajimensis (imperforate species) had a different Mg/Ca temperature equation form those of perforate species. The combined Mg/Ca temperature and delta O-18 temperature equations are yielded using the least square method as follows: Mg/Ca = 2.73 T + 74.7 for three perforate species, which is applicable to a temperature range between 21 degrees C to 30 degrees C. The temperature relation of delta O-18 is different even among perforate species. We observed that the delta O-18 values were closer to the equilibrium of pure calcite than those of high-magnesium calcite. The delta O-18 temperature (7) equations are yielded using the least square method as follows: T= 15.1-6.17 (delta O-18, delta O-18(sw)) for C. gaudichaudii, T = 17.7-5.14 (delta O-18(c) - delta O-18(sw)) for N. calcar, and T = 16.1-5.10 (delta O-18(c),- delta O-18(sw)) for B. sphaerulata. A species-specific calibration is necessary for the relation between delta O-18 and temperature. As long as the optimum temperature range is the same, foraminifers belonging to the Calcarinidae show the same Mg/Ca temperature relationship.