A comparison of cryogel scaffolds to identify an appropriate structure for promoting bone regeneration

To create an ideal graft substitute for regenerating bone, the scaffold should possess osteoconductive, osteoinductive, and osteogenic properties. Hydrogels are a very common scaffold, but the mechanical integrity and nanoporous structure are not advantageous for bone regeneration. Cryogelation is a technique in which the controlled freezing and thawing of a polymer creates a spongy, macroporous structure with ideal structural characteristics and promising mechanical stability. Hydrogels and cryogels of three different materials (chitosan-gelatin, N-vinyl-2-pyrrolidone, and silk fibroin (SF)) were compared to assess the optimal material and form of scaffold for this application. Cryogel and hydrogel structures were tested in parallel to evaluate porosity, swelling, mechanical integrity, cellular infiltration, and mineralization potential. Cryogels proved superior to hydrogels based on swelling potential and mechanical properties. Among the cryogels, SF demonstrated high pore diameter and area, mineralization upon cellular infiltration, and the largest presence of osteocalcin, a marker of bone formation. These results demonstrate the practicality of cryogels for a bone regeneration application and identify SF as a potential material choice.