Lost in Regulation: Nord Stream 2 and the Limits of the European Commission's Geo-Economic Power

Scholars of the EU's external relations have long debated the question which 'power' the EU represents. When it comes to the EU's external energy relations, there is a convergence of views that the Commission has begun to assert its regulatory power beyond its own borders. Yet, few scholars have attempted to open the black box of this 'liberal mercantilist' model. This paper aims to fill that gap by process tracing and explaining the Commission's attempts to stymie the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline project. Our analysis shows that the Commission has attempted, largely in vein, to achieve geopolitical ends through legal means. We find that this outcome can be explained through the lens of new integration theories. Our analysis illustrates both the limits of the Commission's regulatory toolbox and its efforts to broaden its mandate and strengthen its regulatory powers.

Automated summary

Scholars have debated the EU's representation of 'power', with a consensus emerging that the Commission is asserting regulatory power externally. This paper fills the gap by tracing the Commission's efforts to block the Nord Stream 2 project. Our analysis shows the Commission's attempts to achieve geopolitical goals through legal means have largely been ineffective.