Instream large wood loads across bioclimatic regions

Instream large wood in forested rivers creates diverse physical and ecological effects and is a vital component of river process and form. The majority of research on wood in rivers has been conducted within a limited geographic range, raising questions about the applicability of resulting insights. We analyze data from 438 river segments in old-growth or unmanaged forests and 250 river segments in lightly managed forests representing diverse environments. We evaluate whether drainage area, channel width, and channel slope influence instream wood load in unmanaged forests across bioclimatic regions. Here we show that, without accounting for variations across regions, these numeric variables do not correlate significantly with wood loads. When accounting for the influence of all available potential influences on wood load in unmanaged forest rivers, bioclimatic region, drainage area, and channel width are the dominant predictors of wood load, and the relationship between wood load and channel width differs between regions. Combining data across bioclimatic regions, unmanaged rivers have significantly greater wood loads than lightly managed forests. Splitting data by bioclimatic region, unmanaged rivers in the northern dry conifer and northern wet conifer regions have significantly greater wood loads than lightly managed forests, but wood loads in the northern wet deciduous region do not differ between unmanaged and lightly managed forests. Our findings suggest that (i) bioclimatic region is a critical factor in predicting and understanding wood dynamics in rivers, (ii) even historic or relatively light levels of timber harvest and wood removal can create persistent differences in wood loads, and (iii) substantial variation in wood load among river segments within a bioclimatic region suggests that riparian forest and river management should focus on processes that maintain wood loads capable of creating desired physical and ecological effects rather than specified volumes of wood.