Model-Based Ideal Testing of GUI Programs-Approach and Case Studies

Traditionally, software testing is aimed at showing the presence of faults. This paper proposes a novel approach to testing graphical user interfaces (GUI) for showing both the presence and absence of faults in the sense of ideal testing. The approach uses a positive testing concept to show that the GUI under consideration (GUC) does what the user expects; to the contrary, the negative testing concept shows that the GUC does not do anything that the user does not expect, building a holistic view. The first step of the approach models the GUC by a finite state machine (FSM) that enables the model-based generation of test cases. This is always possible as the GUIs are considered as strictly sequential processes. The next step converts the FSM to an equivalent regular expression (RE) that will be analyzed first to construct test selection criteria for excluding redundant test cases and construct test coverage criteria for terminating the positive test process. Both criteria enable us to assess the adequacy and efficiency of the positive tests performed. The negative tests will be realized by systematically mutating the FSM to model faults, the absence of which are to be shown. Those mutant FSMs will be handled and assessed in the same way as in positive testing. Two case studies illustrate and validate the approach; the experiments' results will be analyzed to discuss the pros and cons of the techniques introduced.

Automated summary

The proposed approach introduces a novel way of software testing for graphical user interfaces, aiming to show both the presence and absence of faults. It utilizes positive and negative testing concepts to build a holistic view, modeling GUIs with finite state machines and converting them to regular expressions for test case generation. Test selection and coverage criteria are then used to assess the adequacy and efficiency of the positive tests, while systematically mutating the FSMs for negative tests to model faults and demonstrate their absence.