Investigating the Effect of Fruit Size on Ripening Recovery of Banana Treated with 1-Methylcyclopropene

Postharvest application of 1-methylcycloprepene (1-MCP) on banana fruit to extend shelf-life and maintain quality is inconsistent as treated fruit do not ripen uniformly. Banana response to 1-MCP treatment can be variable due to within-bunch variation in fruit size, composition, and maturity. Therefore, the present study investigated whether fruit size variation explains variability in ripening recovery. To investigate this relationship, large, medium, and small fruit were treated with 0 nL L-1 1-MCP (control), 400 nL L-1 1-MCP and 50 mu L L-1 ethephon + 400 nL L-1 1-MCP. Fruit were then ripened using 800 mu L L-1 ethephon and stored at 23 degrees C for 30 d. Irrespective of fruit size, treating banana with 1-MCP and ethephon + 1-MCP prolonged shelf-life by 30 d compared to control, which were fully ripe at 15 d for medium and large fruit, and 20 d for small fruit. 1-MCP significantly delayed yellow colour development (colour stage 4), chlorophyll degradation (97.4 mu g/g), and sucrose (2.57 mg/g) and glucose (0.86 mg/g) accumulation in small compared to medium and large fruit. However, firmness (56.13 N) and starch (0.68 mg/g) were significantly lower in 1-MCP-treated small-sized fruit compared to medium and large fruit. Moisture loss was also significantly higher (19.49%) in 1-MCP-treated small fruit compared to medium (14.89%) and large (18.11%). Combined ethephon and 1-MCP allowed for an increase in ripening in small, medium, and large fruit. Overall, medium and large fruit treated with 1-MCP and ethephon + 1-MCP recovered their ripening capacity better compared to small fruit. The results demonstrate that 1-MCP efficacy is influenced by fruit size, whereas ethephon + 1-MCP treatment was consistent across small, medium, and large fruit. The effect of fruit size on 1-MCP efficacy might explain the inconsistency of the treatment in the banana fruit. Therefore, it is important to apply 1-MCP on fruit of approximately the same size to achieve the full benefit of the treatment. Moreover, fruit treated with 1-MCP + ethephon recovered their ripening capacity, irrespective of size, suggesting that it is a beneficial treatment.

Automated summary

The study found that the efficacy of 1-MCP treatment is influenced by fruit size, while the effect of ethephon + 1-MCP treatment is consistent across different sizes of fruit. Fruit size may contribute to the inconsistency of 1-MCP treatment, therefore it is important to treat fruit of similar sizes to achieve maximum benefits.