Educational interventions for improving nursing shift handovers: A systematic review

Aim: This study analyzed the components of educational interventions for handovers among nursing students and nurses. Background: A handover is a communication process that occurs when patient care responsibilities and rights are transferred from one nurse to another. This process is important in nursing to ensure the continuity of nursing care and patient safety. Design: A systematic literature review of Korean and international studies was conducted to identify the components of handover educational programs for nursing students and nurses and analyze their effects, thereby providing a basis for the further development of these programs. Methods: Studies published in English or Korean no later than June 30, 2022, were found via an electronic database search using the MEDLINE, Embase, and CINAHL databases. Three reviewers independently evaluated all the studies. These studies focused on educational interventions for nursing students and nurses regarding covering shift-to-shift nursing handovers. After reviewing 1971 extracted articles, 18 satisfied the inclusion criteria. Results: Nine articles involved nursing students and nine involved nurses. Four articles covered bedside handovers as educational topics. Educational methods included lectures and active practice. Active practice comprised demonstrations, role-play, and feedback. The main content areas of the educational programs were an introduction to handovers; training regarding how to extract important information for handovers; and strategies using informatic and thematic structures, such as mnemonics, and concept mapping. The patient cases for roleplay were provided in forms of written scenarios, virtual electronic charts, videos, scenario-based simulated situations, and actual patient cases assigned in clinical practice. The effects of the educational interventions were evaluated regarding knowledge, performance, and self-efficacy. Performance and self-efficacy were significantly higher in a study in which the intervention group was provided additional individual feedback compared to the control group and in a study in which the intervention group received multiple additional practice opportunities. Conclusions: Handover education for nursing students and nurses should include individual feedback, demonstrations, and opportunities to practice to improve their performance and self-efficacy. Feedback methods should be further developed to increase the effectiveness of educational programs. Sample cases involving patients should be devised to increase these opportunities, and methods for improving educator efficiency should be identified.

Automated summary

This study analyzed the components and effects of educational interventions for handovers among nursing students and nurses. The findings suggest that handover education should include individual feedback, demonstrations, and opportunities to practice. Improving educator efficiency and developing effective feedback methods are important for enhancing the effectiveness of educational programs.