Ragone plots of material-based hydrogen storage systems

This paper presents an analytical assessment of the energy-power relationship for different material-based hydrogen storage systems, namely Metal Hydrides (MHs) and Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers (LOHCs). Storage systems are subjected to continuous flow discharge processes through suitable control systems to meet constant specific power demands of end users. By means of reasonable assumptions, analytical expressions of the time-dependent degree of hydrogenation (representing the state of charge) are obtained to find the amount of hydrogen discharged (delivered energy) as a function of flow rate (required power). The results are first presented in the form of dimensionless Ragone plots to highlight the dependence of the amount of discharged hydrogen on the required mass flow rate. Numerical examples are presented for a couple of illustrative systems. Moreover, these analytical expressions are shown to produce very similar results to those obtained with the solution of a dynamic model, including, beyond the kinetic equation, mass and energy conservation applied to the reactor. The results show a significant impact of power demand on the released hydrogen for most systems, similar to that of capacitors, due to the dependence of the rate of reaction on the degree of hydrogenation: as a consequence, the amount of energy that can be delivered to an end user decreases substantially with an increase in the required power, resulting in a poor utilisation factor. Based on these results, MHs exhibit almost first-order kinetics and can sustain efficient discharge with theoretical specific power up to 2 kW/kg (rate of chemical energy delivered per unit mass of active substance), corresponding to a discharge duration of the order of 0.25 h; some LOHCs are limited by second-order kinetics and the specific power should be lower than 1 kW/kg, with discharge durations that must be above 2 hour, to ensure effective utilisation of stored hydrogen.

Automated summary

This paper presents an analytical assessment of the energy-power relationship for different material-based hydrogen storage systems. It explores the impact of power demand on the amount of discharged hydrogen and the utilization factor. The results show that metal hydrides have higher specific power compared to liquid organic hydrogen carriers. The study provides insights into the discharge duration and energy utilization of hydrogen storage systems.