Revisiting Scenarios of Using Refactoring Techniques to Improve Software Systems Quality

Refactoring is one of the most widely used techniques in practice to improve the quality of existing software. However, it is observed that refactoring does not continually improve all software quality attributes. Recent studies indicated that different refactoring techniques have significantly different, sometimes opposite, and conflicting effects on software quality attributes. In other words, there is contradictory evidence on the refactoring benefit. As a result, developers face challenges in selecting appropriate refactoring techniques when they use them to improve software quality. To the best of our knowledge, no study has investigated factors that may explain inconsistent or diverging results concerning the effect of refactoring techniques on software quality. Therefore, in this study, scenarios of using refactoring techniques factor have been identified, investigated, and thoroughly analyzed. Ten of the most commonly used refactoring techniques in practice have been chosen and individually applied in seven case studies of varying sizes (small, medium, and large). The Quality Model for Object-Oriented Design (QMOOD) is used to assess how refactoring techniques affect quality attributes. The findings provide strong evidence that this factor plays a significant role in producing the various effects of refactoring techniques on quality attributes. These findings can help software developers understand how to use refactoring techniques to improve software quality while taking this factor into account. The best scenario for using each refactoring technique to improve software system quality has been identified. The findings can provide guidelines for software developers to use refactoring techniques to improve the quality of software systems based on the best scenarios of using the refactoring techniques.

Automated summary

Refactoring is a widely used technique to improve software quality, but different refactoring techniques have varying effects on quality attributes. This study examines scenarios of using refactoring techniques and finds that this factor plays a significant role in determining their effects on software quality.