Passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis replicates soleus but not gastrocnemius muscle function during stance in gait: Insights for orthosis prescription

Background: Passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis characteristics, including bending stiffness, should be customized for individuals. However, while conventions for customizing passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis characteristics are often described and implemented in clinical practice, there is little evidence to explain their biomechanical rationale. Objectives: To develop and combine a model of a customized passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis with a healthy musculoskeletal model and use simulation tools to explore the influence of passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis bending stiffness on plantar flexor function during gait. Study design: Dual case study. Methods: The customized passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis characteristics were integrated into a healthy musculoskeletal model available in OpenSim. Quasi-static forward dynamic simulations tracked experimental gait data under several passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis conditions. Predicted muscle activations were calculated through a computed muscle control optimization scheme. Results: Simulations predicted that the passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthoses substituted for soleus but not gastrocnemius function. Induced acceleration analyses revealed the passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis acts like a uniarticular plantar flexor by inducing knee extension accelerations, which are counterproductive to natural knee kinematics in early midstance. Conclusion: These passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthoses can provide plantar flexion moments during mid and late stance to supplement insufficient plantar flexor strength. However, the passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthoses negatively influenced knee kinematics in early midstance. Clinical relevance Identifying the role of passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis stiffness during gait provides biomechanical rationale for how to customize passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthoses for patients. Furthermore, these findings can be used in the future as the basis for developing objective prescription models to help drive the customization of passive-dynamic ankle-foot orthosis characteristics.