Head and neck cancer with synchronous nodules of the lung as a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge-A systematic review

Head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) often presents with synchronous nodules of the lung (sNL), which may be benign nodules, second primary malignancies or metastases of HNSCC. We sought to gain an insight into the incidence of sNL and synchronous second primary of the lung (sSPML) in HNSCC patients and current opinions on useful diagnostic and therapeutic approaches. We conducted a systematic search of the PubMed database for articles that reported the simultaneous detection of HNSCC and sNL/sPML, within the timeframe of diagnosis and staging. Only studies involving humans were included, without restrictions for sex, age, ethnicity, or smoking history. All articles were categorised according to the Oxford Centre of Evidence-Based Medicine levels and their data collected. Data from 24 studies were analysed. Amongst HNSCC, the mean overall incidence rate of sNL and sSPML was 11.4% (range: 1.3-27%) and 2.95% (range: 0.4-7.4%), respectively. The possibility of a sNL to be a sSPML cannot be ignored (mean: 35.2%). Studies investigating smoking habits showed that the majority (98-100%) of HNSCC patients with sSPML were previous or active smokers. Detection of human papillomavirus through DNA analysis, p16 immunohistochemistry, and identification of clonal evolution were useful in differentiating metastasis from sSPML. 18FDG-PET scan was the most reliable method to diagnose sSPML (sensitivity: 95%; specificity: 96%; positive predictive value: 80%). With early sSPML detection and curative treatment, the 5-year overall survival rate is 34-47%. However, the proposed advantage of early detection warrants further evidence-based justification.

Automated summary

Head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) often presents with synchronous nodules of the lung (sNL), which may be benign, secondary malignancies or metastases. The incidence rate of sNL and synchronous second primary of the lung (sSPML) in HNSCC is 11.4% and 2.95% respectively. Smoking is a common risk factor for sSPML in HNSCC patients. Various diagnostic methods, including DNA analysis and PET scan, can help differentiate sSPML from metastasis. Early detection and treatment of sSPML improve survival rates, but further evidence is needed to support this advantage.