Removal of site effects and enhancement of signal using dual projection independent component analysis for pooling multi-site MRI data

Combining magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data from multi-site studies is a popular approach for constructing larger datasets to greatly enhance the reliability and reproducibility of neuroscience research. However, the scanner/site variability is a significant confound that complicates the interpretation of the results, so effective and complete removal of the scanner/site variability is necessary to realise the full advantages of pooling multi-site datasets. Independent component analysis (ICA) and general linear model (GLM) based harmonisation methods are the two primary methods used to eliminate scanner/site effects. Unfortunately, there are challenges with both ICA-based and GLM-based harmonisation methods to remove site effects completely when the signals of interest and scanner/site effects-related variables are correlated, which may occur in neuroscience studies. In this study, we propose an effective and powerful harmonisation strategy that implements dual projection (DP) theory based on ICA to remove the scanner/site effects more completely. This method can separate the signal effects correlated with site variables from the identified site effects for removal without losing signals of interest. Both simulations and vivo structural MRI datasets, including a dataset from Autism Brain Imaging Data Exchange II and a travelling subject dataset from the Strategic Research Program for Brain Sciences, were used to test the performance of a DP-based ICA harmonisation method. Results show that DP-based ICA harmonisation has superior performance for removing site effects and enhancing the sensitivity to detect signals of interest as compared with GLM-based and conventional ICA harmonisation methods. We propose an effective and powerful harmonisation strategy that implements dual-projection (DP) theory based on independent component analysis (ICA) to remove the site effects. This method can harmonise site effects without losing signals of interest. Harmonisation of multi-site real datasets shows that ICA-DP harmonisation has superior performance for removing site effects and preserving the signals of interest compared to ComBat and conventional ICA harmonisation methods.image

Automated summary

This study proposes an effective and powerful harmonisation strategy based on dual-projection (DP) theory of independent component analysis (ICA) to remove scanner/site effects while preserving signals of interest. The method shows superior performance compared to GLM-based and conventional ICA harmonisation methods in both simulation and real datasets.