On unusual conditions for the exhumation of subducted oceanic crustal rocks: How to make rocks hotter than models

The thermal structure of subduction zones controls many important processes such as metamorphic devolatilization, arc magmatism, and seismicity. However, the thermal state of subducted oceanic slab predicted by subduction zone thermal models down to & SIM;80 km depth is systematically cooler than inferred from exhumed metamorphic slab rocks, raising questions about the current understanding of subduction dynamics portrayed by these models. Upon synthesizing previous petrological studies and estimating slab ages of ancient subduction zones from metamorphic terranes, we think that exhumation of subducted oceanic metamorphic rocks is extremely rare and likely requires unusual processes that are not an integral component of normal subduction dynamics. We construct simple numerical scenarios to illustrate how the thermal regime under some unusual conditions at the beginning and ending stages of a subduction margin may deviate from the normal subduction process. At the beginning stage of subduction, a shallow maximum decoupling depth (MDD) between the slab and mantle wedge enables viscous mantle wedge flow to reach a shallow depth, bringing heat to make slab rocks warmer than in a mature subduction zone. At the ending stage of subduction, if subduction cessation is in the form of slab stalling and if the stalled slab is not immediately exhumed, the slab rocks can be warmed up by the heat from the warm mantle wedge and underlying asthenosphere. In either situation, the slab rocks can be much warmer than normal before they are exhumed by other dynamic processes. Observed exhumed rocks are not expected to represent the normal subduction process and should not be directly compared with thermal models that are designed for the normal process. To extract important information about general geodynamic processes from these rocks, we must first understand the processes these rocks went through.& COPY; 2023 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Automated summary

The thermal structure of subduction zones plays a crucial role in various geological processes. However, the current understanding of subduction dynamics based on thermal models has been questioned due to inconsistencies with exhumed metamorphic slab rocks. Through a synthesis of petrological studies and estimation of slab ages, it is concluded that the exhumation of subducted oceanic rocks is rare and requires unusual processes.