Generalized moving least squares vs. radial basis function finite difference methods for approximating surface derivatives

Approximating differential operators defined on two-dimensional surfaces is an important problem that arises in many areas of science and engineering. Over the past ten years, localized meshfree methods based on generalized moving least squares (GMLS) and radial basis function finite differences (RBF-FD) have been shown to be effective for this task as they can give high orders of accuracy at low computational cost, and they can be applied to surfaces defined only by point clouds. However, there have yet to be any studies that perform a direct comparison of these methods for approximating surface differential operators (SDOs). The first purpose of this work is to fill that gap. For this comparison, we focus on an RBF-FD method based on polyharmonic spline kernels and polynomials (PHS+Poly) since they are most closely related to the GMLS method. Additionally, we use a relatively new technique for approximating SDOs with RBF-FD called the tangent plane method since it is simpler than previous techniques and natural to use with PHS+Poly RBF-FD. The second purpose of this work is to relate the tangent plane formulation of SDOs to the local coordinate formulation used in GMLS and to show that they are equivalent when the tangent space to the surface is known exactly. The final purpose is to use ideas from the GMLS SDO formulation to derive a new RBF-FD method for approximating the tangent space for a point cloud surface when it is unknown. For the numerical comparisons of the methods, we examine their convergence rates for approximating the surface gradient, divergence, and Laplacian as the point clouds are refined for various parameter choices. We also compare their efficiency in terms of accuracy per computational cost, both when including and excluding setup costs.

Automated summary

Approximating differential operators on two-dimensional surfaces is a crucial problem in various fields. Localized meshfree methods, such as generalized moving least squares (GMLS) and radial basis function finite differences (RBF-FD), have been proven effective and efficient in achieving high accuracy at low computational cost for this task. However, a direct comparison of these methods for approximating surface differential operators (SDOs) has not been conducted yet. This study aims to fill this gap and compare the performance of GMLS with an RBF-FD method based on polyharmonic spline kernels and polynomials (PHS+Poly). Furthermore, we investigate the relationship between the tangent plane formulation of SDOs and the local coordinate formulation used in GMLS, and propose a new RBF-FD method for approximating the tangent space of an unknown point cloud surface using ideas from the GMLS SDO formulation. Evaluation: 8/10.