Effects of contour farming and tillage practices on soil erosion processes in a hummocky watershed. A model-based case study highlighting the role of tramline tracks

To reduce water erosion, one of the most severe land degradation processes on arable soils, conservation measures such as contour farming or reduced tillage practices can be applied. The general effectiveness of these measures on reducing soil erosion is well understood, however, little is known about the influence on tramline tracks, which have considerable impact on the transport of sediment and runoff. This study assesses the impact of reduced and conventional tillage and slope-related tramline directions on runoff and soil erosion rates at catchment level. For this purpose, a published and freely available dataset was used consisting of soil loss and runoff data modelled for a single soil erosion event considering courses and structural properties of tramlines (cf. Saggau et al., 2022). The orientation of tramlines against the slope direction was defined as contouring efficiency (Cef) and calculated by an approach that relates slope and tramline directions. Finally, results of the statistical analyses are compared with mapped soil erosion data. Results show that i) high-resolution derivation of Cef, based on tramlines, shows reasonable results in capturing variations in slope curvatures within the fields, ii) increased Cefs can significantly reduce runoff and soil erosion in tramlines and, iii) reduced tillage indicates significantly lower runoff and soil erosion rates in tramlines and cultivated areas. The results reveal that tramlines have strong interrelations with surface runoff, water connectivity and soil erosion. The consideration of tramlines in process-based models should be employed in other model approaches as it improves assessments of soil erosion risk and efficiencies of conservation measures, which are necessary in taking appropriate actions in support of soil and water conservation.

Automated summary

To reduce water erosion on arable soils, conservation measures such as contour farming or reduced tillage practices can be applied. This study assesses the impact of reduced and conventional tillage and slope-related tramline directions on runoff and soil erosion rates. Results show that tramlines have strong interrelations with surface runoff, water connectivity, and soil erosion, highlighting the importance of considering tramlines in process-based models for better assessment of soil erosion risk and conservation measure efficiencies.