Science education with multilingual learners: Equity as access and equity as transformation

Research in science education with multilingual learners (MLs) has expanded rapidly. This rapid expansion can be situated within a larger dialogue about what it means to provide minoritized students with an equitable education. Whereas some conceptions of equity focus on ensuring all students have access to the knowledge, practices, and language normatively valued in K-12 schools (equity as access), increasingly prominent conceptions focus on transforming those knowledge, practices, and language in ways that center minoritized students and their communities (equity as transformation). In this article, we argue that conceptions of equity provide a useful lens for understanding emerging research in science education with MLs and for charting a research agenda. We begin by tracing how conceptions of equity have evolved in parallel across STEM and multilingual education. Then, we provide an overview of recent developments from demographic, theoretical, and policy perspectives. In the context of these developments, we provide a conceptual synthesis of emerging research by our team of early-career scholars in three areas: (a) learning, (b) assessment, and (c) teacher education. Within each area, we unpack the research efforts in terms of how they attend to equity as access while pushing toward equity as transformation. Finally, we propose a research agenda for science education with MLs that builds on and extends these efforts. We close by offering recommendations for making this research agenda coherent and impactful: (a) being explicit about our conceptions of equity, (b) paying attention to the interplay of structure and agency, and (c) promoting interdisciplinary collaboration.

Automated summary

Research in science education with multilingual learners has expanded rapidly. Conceptions of equity, focusing on access or transformation, provide a useful lens for understanding this research and charting a research agenda. This article traces the evolution of equity in STEM and multilingual education, provides an overview of recent developments, and synthesizes emerging research in three areas: learning, assessment, and teacher education. The article also proposes a research agenda and offers recommendations for making the agenda coherent and impactful, including being explicit about equity conceptions and promoting interdisciplinary collaboration.