Same same but different: dopamine transporter SPECT on scanners with CZT vs. NaI detectors

Background The aims of this study were to establish a normal database (NDB) for semiquantification of dopamine transporter (DAT) single-photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) with [I-123]FP-CIT on a cadmium zinc telluride (CZT) camera, test the preexisting NaI-derived NDB for use in CZT scans, and compare the diagnostic findings in subjects imaged with a CZT scanner with either the preexisting NaI-based NDB or our newly defined CZT NDB.Methods The sample comprised 73 subjects with clinically uncertain parkinsonian syndrome (PS) who prospectively underwent [I-123]FP-CIT SPECT on a CZT camera according to standard guidelines with identical acquisition and reconstruction protocols (DaTQUANT). Two experienced readers visually assessed the images and binarized the subjects into non-neurodegenerative PS and neurodegenerative PS. Twenty-five subjects from the non-neurodegenerative PS subgroup were randomly selected to establish a CZT NDB. The remaining 48 subjects were defined as test group. DaTQUANT was used to determine the specific binding ratio (SBR). For the test group, SBR values were transformed to z-scores for the putamen utilizing both the CZT NDB and the manufacturer-provided NaI-based NDB (GE NDB). A predefined fixed cut-off of -2 was used for dichotomization of z-scores to classify neurodegenerative and non-neurodegenerative PS. Performance of semiquantification using the two NDB to identify subjects with neurodegenerative PS was assessed in comparison with the visual rating. Furthermore, a randomized head-to-head comparison of both detector systems was performed semiquantitatively in a subset of 32 out of all 73 subjects.Results Compared to the visual rating as reference, semiquantification based on the dedicated CZT NDB led to fewer discordant ratings than the GE NDB in CZT scans (3 vs. 8 out of 48 subjects). This can be attributed to the putaminal z-scores being consistently higher with the GE NDB on a CZT camera (median absolute difference of 1.68), suggesting an optimal cut-off of -0.5 for the GE NDB instead of -2.0. Average binding ratios and z-scores were significantly lower in CZT compared to NaI data.Conclusions Use of a dedicated, CZT-derived NDB is recommended in [I-123]FP-CIT SPECT with a CZT camera since it improves agreement between semiquantification and visual assessment.

Automated summary

The study aimed to establish a normal database for semiquantification of DAT SPECT using [I-123]FP-CIT on a CZT camera, compare it with the preexisting NaI-derived database, and evaluate its diagnostic findings. The results showed that semiquantification based on the CZT NDB led to fewer discordant ratings compared to the GE NDB in CZT scans, improving agreement between semiquantification and visual assessment.