Measurement of student engagement in health professions education: a review of literature

Student engagement is a complex multidimensional construct that has attained great interest in health professions education (HPE). Definition and conceptualization of student engagement is an important step that should drive the development of the instruments for its measurement. We have recently proposed a comprehensive framework for student engagement in HPE with a definition of engagement as student investment of time and energy in academic and non-academic experiences that include learning, teaching, research, governance, and community activities. The dimensions of student engagement in this framework included the cognitive, affective, behavioral, agentic, and socio-cultural. Guided by the student engagement framework, this non-systematic review aims to identify, critically appraise, and summarize the existing methods for measuring student engagement in HPE. Extrapolating from higher education literature, we attempted to link the theoretical perspectives of student engagement with the published methods of its measurement in HPE context. In addition, we have described the different methods of measuring student engagement including self-report surveys, real time measures, direct observation, interviews/focus groups, and the use of multiple instruments. The span of engagement dimensions measured by self-report surveys ranges from one to five dimensions. However, measurement of agentic and sociocultural dimensions of engagement in HPE is still limited and further research is required. We have also reflected on the existing methods of measuring engagement of students as active partners in HPE. The review also describes the advantages, limitations, and psychometric properties of each method for measuring student engagement. We ended the review with a guiding conclusion on how to develop and select an instrument for measuring student engagement in HPE. Finally, we addressed the gaps in the literature about measuring engagement of HPE students and future research plans.

Automated summary

Student engagement is a complex construct in health professions education that has gained significant interest. It is important to define and conceptualize student engagement in order to develop measurement instruments. This review explores the existing methods for measuring student engagement in health professions education, focusing on self-report surveys, real-time measures, direct observation, interviews/focus groups, and the use of multiple instruments. The dimensions of engagement measured by self-report surveys range from one to five, with limited measurement of the agentic and socio-cultural dimensions. The review also discusses the advantages, limitations, and psychometric properties of each method, and provides suggestions for developing and selecting measurement instruments for student engagement in health professions education.