The evolving copiotrophic/oligotrophic dichotomy: From Winogradsky to physiology and genomics

Nearly 100 years ago, Winogradsky published a classic communication in which he described two groups of microbes, zymogenic and autochthonous. When organic matter penetrates the soil, zymogenic microbes quickly multiply and degrade it, then giving way to the slow combustion of autochthonous microbes. Although the text was originally written in French, it is often cited by English-speaking authors. We undertook a complete translation of the 1924 publication, which we provide as Supporting information. Here, we introduce the translation and describe how the zymogenic/autochthonous dichotomy shaped research questions in the study of microbial diversity and physiology. We also identify in the literature three additional and closely related dichotomies, which we propose to call exclusive copiotrophs/oligotrophs, coexisting copiotrophs/oligotrophs and fast-growing/slow-growing microbes. While Winogradsky focussed on a successional view of microbial populations over time, the current discussion is focussed on the differences in the specific growth rate of microbes as a function of the concentration of a given limiting substrate. In the future, it will be relevant to keep in mind both nutrient-focussed and time-focussed microbial dichotomies and to design experiments with both isolated laboratory cultures and multi-species communities in the spirit of Winogradsky's direct method.

Automated summary

Nearly 100 years ago, Winogradsky published a classic communication describing two groups of microbes, zymogenic and autochthonous. The paper, originally written in French, has been widely cited by English-speaking authors. In this study, the authors provide a complete translation of the publication and discuss the impact of the zymogenic/autochthonous dichotomy on microbial diversity and physiology research. They also propose three additional dichotomies and emphasize the importance of considering both nutrient-focused and time-focused microbial classifications in future experiments.