Which civil religion? Partisanship, Christian nationalism, and the dimensions of civil religion in the United States

Civil religion has been described as the common elements of religious orientation that the great majority of Americans share. In an age of partisan division, there have been calls for a revitalized civil religion, but the idea that civil religion can be unifying has been debated. In this paper, we investigate whether civil religion can be unifying, or is it fractured by partisanship? To address this, we use two strategies. First, we created a civil religion battery and deployed it on two different cross-sectional surveys. The results indicate that there are two dimensions to civil religion. These dimensions are distinct from Christian nationalism and structured along partisan lines. Second, we developed two survey experiments to understand the dimensions of civil religion and improve on the causal mechanisms that link civil religion to political behavior. Results indicate that, rather than promoting unity, civil religion is interpreted through partisan lenses.

Automated summary

This paper investigates whether civil religion can be unifying or is fractured by partisanship. The study finds that civil religion has two dimensions, distinct from Christian nationalism and structured along partisan lines. Additionally, the research reveals that civil religion is interpreted through partisan lenses rather than promoting unity.