4.7 Review

A systematic review and meta-analysis of the evidence on learning during the COVID-19 pandemic

相关参考文献

注意:仅列出部分参考文献,下载原文获取全部文献信息。
Article Education & Educational Research

Learning Loss in Vulnerable Student Populations After the First Covid-19 School Closure in the Netherlands

Tessa M. Schuurman et al.

Summary: This study examined the impact of the first school closure on vulnerable student groups in a school with a high percentage of students from disadvantaged backgrounds in the Netherlands. The findings showed that the school closures caused a discontinuity in students' academic growth on standardized tests, resulting in an average learning loss of 2.47 months in mathematics and 2.35 months in reading comprehension, exceeding the duration of the closure. The study highlights the contribution of school closures to educational inequality and identifies the students who may require additional support to mitigate the adverse consequences of the lockdowns.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Sociology

No evidence of a major learning slide 14 months into the COVID-19 pandemic in Denmark

Jesper Fels Birkelund et al.

Summary: This study examines the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on children's academic performance in Denmark after 14 months. The findings suggest that there is no significant learning loss, and in some cases, students showed improvement. The length of school closures seemed to play a role, with older children experiencing longer closures. Surprisingly, there was no evidence of widening learning gaps based on family background.

EUROPEAN SOCIETIES (2023)

Article Economics

Are there no wage returns to compulsory schooling in Germany? A reassessment

Kamila Cygan-Rehm

Summary: This study replicates and challenges the findings of Pischke and von Wachter on zero wage returns to compulsory schooling in Germany. The results show that their estimates are sensitive to minor changes in sample restrictions and model specifications, potentially confounded by previously unconsidered institutional details. This calls into question the conclusion that compulsory schooling in Germany yields no wage returns.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECONOMETRICS (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

The effect of school closures on standardised student test outcomes

Joana Elisa Maldonado et al.

Summary: School closures in 2020 due to the COVID-19 crisis resulted in significant learning losses in mathematics and Dutch for students in the Flemish region of Belgium, with inequality within and across schools increasing.

BRITISH EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH JOURNAL (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Sharp increase in inequality in education in times of the COVID-19-pandemic

Carla Haelermans et al.

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has worsened educational inequality, with school closures and distance learning disproportionately affecting children from lower-educated and poorer families. A study in the Netherlands found significant disparities in learning loss based on parental education and income, highlighting the need for targeted interventions for vulnerable students.

PLOS ONE (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Estimation of the fundamental learning loss and learning poverty related to COVID-19 pandemic in Mexico

Felipe J. Hevia et al.

Summary: Evidence shows learning loss due to the COVID-19 pandemic in Mexico, specifically in reading and numeracy. Disparities in learning outcomes by gender and socio-economic status have increased. Urgent action is needed to develop a clear strategy for personalized diagnoses and remedial courses to address the learning loss.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

The Impact of COVID-19-Related School Closures on Student Achievement-A Meta-Analysis

Christoph Koenig et al.

Summary: COVID-19 has led to the closure of schools worldwide and the adoption of remote learning. This article presents a meta-analysis of the average impact of COVID-19-related school closures on students, revealing a significant negative effect. Younger students were more affected compared to older students, and the negative impact decreased with continued lockdowns.

EDUCATIONAL MEASUREMENT-ISSUES AND PRACTICE (2022)

Article Psychology, Biological

The impacts of remote learning in secondary education during the pandemic in Brazil

Guilherme Lichand et al.

Summary: Using a differences-in-differences approach, the study estimates the effects of remote learning in Sao Paulo, Brazil during the pandemic. The findings suggest that middle- and high-school students learned only 27.5% of the in-person equivalent and that dropout risk increased by 365%. Partially resuming in-person classes increased test scores by 20% relative to the control group.

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Did students learn less during the COVID-19 pandemic? Reading and mathematics competencies before and after the first pandemic wave

Johannes Schult et al.

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted classes in spring 2020 and led to a significant learning loss for students, particularly those with lower achievement. Remote learning environments presented challenges for teachers, and students had less time for learning. A study on fifth graders in Baden-Wurttemberg, Germany revealed slightly lower competence scores in 2020 compared to previous years, especially in reading and mathematics. Low-achieving students in mathematics seem to have a learning backlog that requires attention in future education.

SCHOOL EFFECTIVENESS AND SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT (2022)

Article Economics

Who Lost the Most? Mathematics Achievement during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Dalit Contini et al.

Summary: This article estimates the impact of school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic on the math skills of primary school children in Italy. Using longitudinal data from the province of Torino, the study finds that the pandemic had a significant negative effect on students' math performance, particularly for girls and high-achieving children of low-educated parents. Additionally, schools with a disadvantaged social composition were most severely affected.

B E JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC ANALYSIS & POLICY (2022)

Article Psychology, Biological

Experimental evidence on learning using low-tech when school is out

Noam Angrist et al.

Summary: This study provides evidence of effective distance education using 'low-tech' mobile phone approaches during school disruptions. Weekly phone tutoring and SMS messages improved learning outcomes cost-effectively.

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

The Effect of COVID on Oral Reading Fluency During the 2020-2021 Academic Year

Benjamin W. Domingue et al.

Summary: This article examines the impact of COVID on students' reading ability. Using data from an oral reading fluency assessment, it is found that students experienced slower growth in reading ability during the first 200 days of the 2020-2021 school year compared to pre-pandemic years. Slower growth was also observed in districts with a high percentage of English language learners and/or students eligible for free and reduced-price lunch.

AERA OPEN (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

No learning loss in Sweden during the pandemic evidence from primary school reading assessments

Anna Eva Hallin et al.

Summary: The study analyzed reading assessment data from Swedish primary school students and found that there was no decrease in word decoding and reading comprehension scores during the COVID-19 pandemic. Students from low socio-economic backgrounds were not particularly affected, and the proportion of students with weak decoding skills did not increase. The study concludes that open schools benefitted Swedish primary school students.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Long-Term Consequences of Repeated School Closures During the COVID-19 Pandemic for Reading and Mathematics Competencies

Johannes Schult et al.

Summary: School closures during the COVID-19 pandemic had a negative impact on students' learning gains. In Germany, two additional waves of the pandemic resulted in more school closures and periods of remote learning. This study examined the academic achievement of fifth-graders in Baden-Wurttemberg before and during the pandemic, using large-scale educational assessments in reading and mathematics. The findings showed that the downward trend in learning levels observed after the first wave of the pandemic halted in reading and continued at a slower rate in mathematical operations. However, there was a partial rebound in mathematical achievements to pre-pandemic levels. Longer school closures were associated with greater learning losses, particularly for low-achieving students and schools with less socio-cultural capital. The results suggest that most teachers and students successfully adapted to the pandemic situation in 2021, but disadvantaged student groups are at risk of further learning losses. Additional support should be provided to compensate for the loss of learning opportunities in the classroom.

FRONTIERS IN EDUCATION (2022)

Review Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Effects of COVID-19-Related School Closures on Student Achievement-A Systematic Review

Svenja Hammerstein et al.

Summary: The study found that school closures due to COVID-19 had a negative impact on student achievement, especially for younger students and those from low socioeconomic status families. Certain measures were identified that may help alleviate these negative effects. The implications of these findings for national educational policies during future school closures are discussed.

FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Building back better to avert a learning catastrophe: Estimating learning loss from COVID-19 school shutdowns in Africa and facilitating short-term and long-term learning recovery

Noam Angrist et al.

Summary: Data from Ethiopia, Kenya, Liberia, Tanzania, and Uganda indicates that the COVID-19 pandemic has caused over half a year's worth of learning loss. Modelling shows that learning deficits in grade 3 students could lead to 2.8 years of lost learning by grade 10. Bold reform in targeted instruction and structured pedagogy could improve learning outcomes even beyond pre-COVID-19 levels.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Measuring human capital using global learning data

Noam Angrist et al.

Summary: Human capital is a critical component of economic development, and comparable global learning metrics are essential for understanding and tracking its formation. The use of international achievement tests, primarily in developed countries, limits analysis of learning patterns in developing countries. Research shows limited global progress in learning, with human capital playing a significant role in explaining income differences across countries. Additionally, considerable heterogeneity exists among income groupings across countries and regions, underscoring the importance of including countries at various stages of economic development in analysis. Our database provides a measure of human capital more closely associated with economic growth than current measures included in existing tables and indexes.

NATURE (2021)

Review Psychology, Biological

Why lockdown and distance learning during the COVID-19 pandemic are likely to increase the social class achievement gap

Sebastien Goudeau et al.

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a shift in education towards distance learning, with teachers and parents playing crucial roles in facilitating this transition. However, this shift has exacerbated social class academic disparities, highlighting the need for further research and recommendations to address the impact of distance learning on educational inequality based on social class.

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR (2021)

Review Pediatrics

School Performance among Children and Adolescents during COVID-19 Pandemic: A Systematic Review

Eleni Panagouli et al.

Summary: The impact of online learning during the pandemic on students' academic performance varies, with some experiencing learning losses and others benefiting, especially in mathematics. Younger students and those with neurodevelopmental disorders or special education needs seem to be more affected.

CHILDREN-BASEL (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Learning loss due to school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic

Per Engzell et al.

Summary: School closures during the pandemic in the Netherlands led to a learning loss of about 3 percentile points or 0.08 standard deviations for primary school students, with a larger impact on students from less-educated homes. The study suggests that the effect is due to the cumulative impact of learned knowledge rather than temporary influences.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Past is future for the era of COVID-19 research in the social sciences

Dalton Conley et al.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Inequality in learning is a major concern after school closures

Herman G. van de Werfhorst

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

COVID-19 learning losses: Early grade reading in South Africa

Cally Ardington et al.

Summary: This paper examines short-term learning losses in reading for grade 2 and 4 students from under-resourced school contexts in South Africa. It finds that students in 2020 lost between 57% and 81% of a year of learning relative to their prepandemic peers. Mitigating these learning losses will require a significant pivot of the education system to optimize learning.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Psychology, Biological

Large socio-economic, geographic and demographic disparities exist in exposure to school closures

Zachary Parolin et al.

Summary: School closures during September to December 2020 were more common in schools with lower math scores and higher proportions of students from racial/ethnic minorities, homelessness, limited English proficiency, and eligibility for free/reduced-price school lunches, indicating potential rising inequalities in learning outcomes.

NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR (2021)

Review Education & Educational Research

Effects of Pandemic-Related School Closures on Pupils' Performance and Learning in Selected Countries: A Rapid Review

Klaus Zierer

Summary: The global coronavirus pandemic has led to school closures worldwide, with many children and young people shifting to distance learning. A rapid review in five countries has shown that these measures have had an impact on students' learning performance.

EDUCATION SCIENCES (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Achievement Gaps in the Wake of COVID-19

Drew H. Bailey et al.

Summary: A survey of education researchers conducted in November 2020 forecasts an increase in achievement gaps between low- and high-income students in U.S elementary schools due to COVID-related disruptions. Researcher predictions show a consensus that the gaps will grow in both math and reading achievement in 2021 and 2022.

EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHER (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Consequences of school closure on access to education: Lessons from the 2013-2016 Ebola pandemic

William C. Smith

Summary: The impact of school closures during both the COVID-19 and Ebola pandemics on children's education has drawn attention. While short-term measures such as remote learning have been taken to keep students engaged, it is crucial to provide comprehensive financial support packages to the most vulnerable groups to minimize post-pandemic inequality.

INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF EDUCATION (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

The impact of COVID-19 on student learning in New South Wales primary schools: an empirical study

Jennifer Gore et al.

Summary: The study found that overall academic performance of students in New South Wales, Australia was not significantly impacted during the COVID-19 pandemic, but there were some students in schools with lower ICSEA indices who showed less growth in mathematics. Most students achieved as expected academically, thanks to the dedicated work of teachers to ensure learning was not compromised despite challenging circumstances.

AUSTRALIAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCHER (2021)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Educational gains of in-person vs. distance learning in primary and secondary schools: A natural experiment during the COVID-19 pandemic school closures in Switzerland

Martin J. Tomasik et al.

Summary: The study found that during the COVID-19 pandemic in Switzerland, primary school students experienced a slowdown in learning pace and an increase in interindividual variance in learning gains, while secondary school students were less affected in terms of learning gains. Distance learning arrangements appear to be an effective substitute for in-person learning in emergency situations, but not all students benefit equally.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Modelling the long-run learning impact of the Covid-19 learning shock: Actions to (more than) mitigate loss

Michelle Kaffenberger

Summary: This paper estimates the potential long-term losses to children's learning from Covid-19 related school closures using a calibrated pedagogical production function model, and models possible gains from two mitigation strategies. It suggests that remediation measures combined with curriculum adjustment can fully mitigate the long-term learning loss and surpass learning levels in the counterfactual of no shock. Systems need to plan for remediation programmes early and ensure they have lasting benefits beyond the immediate reopening period.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Article Economics

The Long-Run Effects of Teacher Strikes: Evidence from Argentina

David Jaume et al.

JOURNAL OF LABOR ECONOMICS (2019)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

ROBINS-I: a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions

Jonathan A. C. Sterne et al.

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2016)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

ROBINS-I: a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions

Jonathan A. C. Sterne et al.

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2016)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Rayyan-a web and mobile app for systematic reviews

Mourad Ouzzani et al.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS (2016)

Article Economics

Assessing the effect of school days and absences on test score performance

Esteban M. Aucejo et al.

ECONOMICS OF EDUCATION REVIEW (2016)

Article Education & Educational Research

The Detrimental Effects of Missing School: Evidence from Urban Siblings

Michael A. Gottfried

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EDUCATION (2011)

Article Mathematical & Computational Biology

A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysis

Michael Borenstein et al.

RESEARCH SYNTHESIS METHODS (2010)

Article Industrial Relations & Labor

Do Teacher Strikes Harm Educational Attainment of Students?

Michele Belot et al.

LABOUR-ENGLAND (2010)

Article Psychology, Educational

ADDRESSING SUMMER READING SETBACK AMONG ECONOMICALLY DISADVANTAGED ELEMENTARY STUDENTS

Richard L. Allington et al.

READING PSYCHOLOGY (2010)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

The harvest plot: A method for synthesising evidence about the differential effects of interventions

David Ogilvie et al.

BMC MEDICAL RESEARCH METHODOLOGY (2008)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Empirical Benchmarks for Interpreting Effect Sizes in Research

Carolyn J. Hill et al.

CHILD DEVELOPMENT PERSPECTIVES (2008)

Article Economics

The long-run educational cost of World War II

A Ichino et al.

JOURNAL OF LABOR ECONOMICS (2004)

Article Education & Educational Research

Schools, achievement, and inequality: A seasonal perspective

KL Alexander et al.

EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION AND POLICY ANALYSIS (2001)